No freedom for Internet community

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

Breakingnews » Breakingnews

No freedom for Internet community

  • Published: 5/02/2009 at 05:58 PM
  • Online news:

Frustrated with what she saw as corporate influence and political bias in Thailand's print media, Chiranuch Premchaiporn helped launch a news website in 2004 to try and filter out the spin.

For a while, it worked as thousands of people visited Prachatai.com every day to read stories they did not see in newspapers and to air their views on the website's lively chat boards.

But everything changed after a 2006 coup ousted premier Thaksin Shinawatra and launched more than two years of highly-charged political turmoil.

"After the coup for a month I got contact from the ICT (Information and Communication Technology) Ministry warning us about some of the comments on our web board," said Chiranuch.

Since then, she has been summoned by police eight times to answer questions about content on her site, while 20 pages on Prachatai.com have been blacklisted and blocked by the authorities in the last five months.

Activists say the blossoming of blogs and Internet chat rooms poring over the kingdom's tumultuous politics have unnerved the authorities, prompting a crushing campaign of censorship to suppress dissenting voices.

The government installed by the coup-makers enacted a law in 2007 policing the Internet, and the current administration of Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva appears to be implementing it with vigour.

More than 4,800 webpages have been blocked since March last year, an ICT official told AFP, notionally because they contain content deemed insulting to Thailand's deeply-revered royal family.

The monarchy's role in the recent political upheaval remains one of the most sensitive subjects in the kingdom, with few local newspapers willing to touch the issue.

"The Thai media is now being completely made tame. They don't dare report lese majeste (insulting the monarchy) cases or any anti-government positions," said Giles Ji Ungpakorn, a political science professor.

"So people express themselves through the Internet, and the government wants to try and put a stop to this."

Abhisit came to power in a parliamentary vote on December 15, 2008 after ongoing protests by the People's Alliance for Democracy (PAD) helped topple the Thaksin-linked ruling party less than a year after it won elections.

The PAD openly claimed the support of the monarchy, while critics of Abhisit say his Democrat Party enjoys the backing of the powerful military.

All the intrigue provided grist for the thriving chatrooms.

"It encouraged people to talk more and the Internet is the most liberal space in Thailand," said Supinya Klangnarong of media group Thai Netizen.

Paris-based media freedom watchdog Reporters Without Borders says Thailand has more than 14 million Internet users, and in January put out a statement asking if Thailand was the world's "new enemy of the Internet".

They deplored the recent arrest of one user after authorities claimed to have matched his computer's Internet address to one used to post online messages deemed defamatory to the monarchy.

At the same time, analysts have said that a record number of investigations are being conducted into lese majeste cases, which carry a jail term of up to 15 years.

Many of them have targeted the media.

Australian writer Harry Nicolaides was jailed for three years on January 19 for defaming His Majesty the King and Crown Prince Maha Vajiralongkorn in a short passage in a 2005 novel.

Political analyst Giles was on January 20 officially charged with lese majeste in connection with a book he wrote about the putsch.

"They are really turning the clock back with a medieval-style witch-hunt going on, and you don't have any transparency," Giles told AFP.

Three issues of British news magazine The Economist have been pulled from the shelves by the Thai distributor in an act of self-censorship because they contained articles about the Thai royals and lese majeste.

When questioned in December about censorship, Abhisit said Thailand was not the only country which blocked websites carrying material deemed offensive.

"The details of which contents are blocked are different according to the traditions and the historical factors of each society," he told AFP.

Supinya says that they have asked many times for a list of the banned web pages, but the authorities refuse to release it.

The communications ministry, meanwhile, has announced it is setting up a "war room" to police the Internet, claiming that thousands more web pages insult the monarchy and therefore threaten national security.

Activists say, however, that the government's policy will eventually backfire as Thais will find an outlet to discuss topics crucial to their country's future.

"You block one, ten more websites will happen," said Chiranuch.

About the author

Writer: AFP

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • Ms. Edith Rose Clampton

    Discussion 14 : 06/02/2009 at 08:10 AM14

    Mr. Shame, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree! Considering his sons were always causing trouble and Daddy cleaned up their mess, even as far as using his connections (corrupt methods) to bail them out, including buying their way out of jail, and buying them into important ranks and posts. Hmm you can't really think that he is any different can you? After all, if this is how he brought up his children, how do you think it will fare for the Thai people? Wake up! Shame on you Shame!

  • shame

    Discussion 13 : 06/02/2009 at 02:36 AM13

    World complaint China has much restriction policy in web access, and thing is much much improved while Thailand are back to the deadhole. What did they afraid for? He shouldn't spend that much time in making his luxury oversea trip instead of making the progress on local economic stimulus plan, there is time but not now while other countries are also facing the same problem. Lack of investment plan, people are afraid of losing the job, so want to keep more cash on hand, instead of spent it for tour at this time. Airline already promote holiday package, check with them if those package are really help or not.

    To Ms Edith, Chalerm may like his son? Is your daddy poor is that mean your are poor too? Eventhose, we should focus on what we have seen today or last 18 months, what Democrats party and PAD bring to Thais. What Thailand are today? Or just tell me to look for better. Sure Thailand will and have to move forward, but tell me where and what. This forum may block 1 day., if they continue to stop negative comments or under condition.

    By the way, I am not RED supporter but look like we need something like this, to make sure we got the balance in Thailand.

  • Wiggers

    Discussion 12 : 06/02/2009 at 01:45 AM12

    The thought police will really have to work when the time will pass. And time will pass. You cannot force people to love others. They have tried to do so in Russia, in North Korea or in Rumania but it always works out differently than the protectors had hoped for. Learn your history!

  • Moo Noi

    Discussion 11 : 06/02/2009 at 12:45 AM11

    I wouldn't read more into the Post's stand than they reported something. They also came out strongly, for a couple of days, when the PAD took over NBT but them it was back to their original platform.

    The media has been targeted and censored since it began in Thailand but the people have to take a firm stand against it. Some things should be censored but eventually you have to have faith that the people will sort out what is interesting and what is not. By stifling the voice of the people you only stop it publicly but their views are just as strong and they will get it out there somehow.

  • Soon enough

    Discussion 10 : 05/02/2009 at 11:04 PM10

    Can someone provide example of Thaksin banning media reporting of his shortcomings?

  • no toxin

    Discussion 9 : 05/02/2009 at 10:55 PM9

    since the coup? get real! thaksin infamously banned media reporting his wrongdoings! be fair people! don't just blame it on the current government!

  • Will

    Discussion 8 : 05/02/2009 at 10:29 PM8

    Thailand is now in very dangerous territory. Let's all hope it doesn't destroy itself. But if that should happen, it has only itself to blame: there are enough examples in history to show that this slide is one that so quickly leads to catastrophe.

  • Drey

    Discussion 7 : 05/02/2009 at 08:58 PM7

    Agree, by publishing this BP is taking a small step to defend its own territory.

    But, BP is already so far out in leftfield with its pointedly one-sided propaganda it is doing a fine job of censorship all by itself.

    ps, my posts have been deleted (5 times to date) by BP between others posts whose written prose were much more "flowery" in nature. It was my message that they didn't like whilst others with differing opinions are able to use any words they wish.

    Take a look at BP's +50,000 www's censored article. You can't even post anything on it. Is that intelligent self-censorship?

    Anyways, this whole fiasco, unfortunately, bodes very ill indeed for all Thai's. Just what is this government thinking? Is it so unstable and worried about its survival it feels the need to trample peoples rights (monarchy topics excluded)?

    The post by david massingham D#2 sums it up nicely.

  • soveny

    Discussion 6 : 05/02/2009 at 08:10 PM6

    First of all, I dont follow anybody here in Thailand or elsewhere. I might support some group or idea and wouldnt dream of following anybody blindly.
    Secondly, the group I have taken side for here might be more dangerous than then the other side, but I cant see that. After all they have never threatened anybody with tanks and arms. Never violated the whole nation with arms. But they have been violated in that way and that leads to fear. Out of fear you can turn anybody into a very very dangerous person.
    Now, to deny them some part of available knowledge on the internet is an other violation to their rights, as I see it. You cant expect them to just swallow one more time and accept it and reconsil with those denying them their freedom.
    I repeat what I said yesterday. Progress in a peacefull way under democratic order or dictatorship with a possible violent outcome.

  • Tommy D Hilfiger

    Discussion 5 : 05/02/2009 at 07:44 PM5

    BP is beginning to turn around in their reporting.
    That's good news and hope they keep it up.
    Welcome to Thailand 2008-9.
    Life under censorship and dictatorship.
    But we love it. We want this kind of life for the next 25 yrs.

    "But everyone must give them a chance."
    "Don't be so negative and dont hate"
    "Absit is the best chance we've got"
    "Thaksin is criminal therefore..."
    Blah Blah Blah

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top