Handshakes won't end student brawls

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

Breakingnews » Breakingnews

Handshakes won't end student brawls

  • Published: 11/02/2009 at 02:43 PM
  • Online news: Breakingnews

The pitched battle between rival students from two well-known vocational colleges in front of a popular Bangkok's shopping mall on Tuesday has proven that there is no simple or cosmetic solution to student violence.

When student representatives of the two rival educational institutes, Uthen Thawai campus of Rajamangala University of Technology and Pathumwan Institute of Technology were made to shake hands and exchange flowers in front of the media on Janaury 28, no one with a modicum of common sense would believe that this publicity stunt arranged by the police would put an end to the decades-old bitter feud between the warring students. At the very best, the gesture would somewhat temporarily eased the tension sparked off by the killing of two students, one on each side, in January. Soon afterward, violence would resume.

Critics of the police’s laughable attempt to patch up the difference between the two rival vocational students couldn’t be more correct in their assessment of the situation and in their prediction of worse to come.  No sooner violence flared up as feared. On Tuesday in f ront of the Mah Boon Krong shopping mall, about 100 students from the two rivals fought each other in a pitched battle with guns, knives and stones in front of thousands of stunned shoppers, bus commuters, motorists and bystanders.

Bursts of gunshots occasionally drowned the ubiquitous noises of various vehicles which jam-packed the road in front of the shopping mall popular among youths. Luckily, no one was shot. One bystander was however beaten up by a group of students apparently mistaken as a rival student. 

During the free-for-all brawl, management of the shopping mall closed down the premise to prevent the feuding students from entering, thus locking up many shoppers inside the mall. The mall itself sustained a broken glass partition apparently from a stone.

Dozens of police from several police stations were mobilised to quell the violence. They managed to nab only three students together with one pistol and a few knives. The rest of the rowdy students managed to escape.

Feuding between rival students of the two schools went back several decades. No one knew exactly what started the feud and why it has kept repeating itself year after year. Some of the students said that it was just a tradition that they had to fight each other for no reasons.

Educators concerned appear to be desperate on how to end the feud. All previous attempts to end the feud have been unsuccessful. The police themselves appear to be at lost in finding a solution. Not to mention the public who are bored and sick with the seemingly endless violence.

But at least the police and the administrators of the two institutes can help prevent violence if not ending the protracted feud. Constant searches of suspected students and the compounds of the two institutes to look for weapons can help reduce the violence while long-term solution remains elusive. Also, the police must get tough with the law-breaking students.

About the author

Writer: Veera Prateepchaikul

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • PROMMR

    Discussion 19 : 13/02/2009 at 01:01 AM19

    comment by meow meow
    This kind of violence is not kids being kids. This endangers everybody involved and everybody any where near these types of incidence.


    Those actually pulling the trigger of the weapons perhaps should be suspended or expelled from school, sent to a military type boot camp, perform community service, or pay for their indiscretion in some way.


    THE parents of these students need to be involved!!!

  • Uncle Sadsy

    Discussion 18 : 12/02/2009 at 08:49 PM18

    I always like to think of a Thomas Cook holiday advertising magazine in another country with " Amazing Thailand " printed accross the front cover with a collage of pictures underneath : PAD blocked airport payed to wear shirts ( u could get stranded ) , Reds at Sanam Luang with human faesces and urine everywhere , a guy on a skateboard with a chicken wing for an arm cut off by the mafia then forced to beg on Suk Rd , a friendly face saying " farang farang lets rip him off " ....and of course a few pics of plastic bags and rubbish everywhere .....or maybe even a pic of some seedy taxi drivers outside Hua Lamphong train station going for sex with 12 yr olds ....what a muppet show ....scoff reply dribble twitch

  • mr.pink

    Discussion 17 : 12/02/2009 at 11:53 AM17

    Wow, Thai college students actually can find guns and use them in a fight.

    And what is the police going to do about that? In my country, people who use firearms without a permit get 20, 30 years behind bars. As a result, only criminals are ever heard of using firearms.

    Amazing Thailand indeed (not that it will stop me from going there, though. Most Thai (except the politicians,PAD,red shirts) are nice people, I know)

  • Meow Meow

    Discussion 16 : 12/02/2009 at 11:26 AM16

    This kind of violence is not kids being kids. This endangers everybody involved and everybody any where near these types of incidences.

    All participants should be video tapes, identified, and sent to prison as an example to the others. That might go a long way to break this chain of violence. Those not actually pulling the trigger of the weapons perhaps should be suspended or expelled from school, sent to a military type boot camp, perform community service, or pay for their indiscretion in some way. It is unacceptable to allow this to continue. The parents of these students need to be involved!

  • PT

    Discussion 15 : 12/02/2009 at 02:03 AM15

    This is so stupid. These students had been fighting since I was student myself at Patumwan Tech. Inst. back in 1986. You can't stop these moron by just hand shake. They will get better with age. There are many good students out there that know how to deal with this dumb kids that wanted to fight. We just avoid the situation and don't wear the lab uniform and walking around.

    They will never change. Don't bother!

  • danzee

    Discussion 14 : 12/02/2009 at 12:13 AM14

    I believe it:
    - a chain reaction and
    - more like a inheritance(initiation process),
    - Hot temper (like all youth, so it just a fuel, but not the catalyst)
    - Peer pressure
    - pride (cultivate when each enrol the school)
    - Network of groupee
    - indirectly encourage

    Put these chemistry together and maybe we can out with a plan (likely to be long term (many years)

  • Somboon

    Discussion 13 : 12/02/2009 at 12:01 AM13

    Of course, handshakes will not solve the problem! Look at the politicians. While one hand is shaking, the other hand is ready to shoot or stab at anytime if you interfere with his/her interests!

    It appears that the executives are thinking mainstream. They ought to look at the issue from the students' point of view. Why did they fight? What are the reasons for the fight? May be of a girlfriend, lack of discipline, lack of responsibility, family issues, etc? There have to be creative solutions, such as create something for them to do after school to show their achievement and be proud of. Try to look from their perspectives.

    I would think music is one possible solution. Music always make people feel good. What would this world be without music? Kids that age love music. Rock 'n Roll and blues (such as Grateful Dead, Stones, Who, Zep, Allman, Gov't Mule, Widespreadpanic, etc.) might do them good. Get them to talk/discuss to vent their feelings. Listen to them. Let them say and question, but attentively listen. The Thai establishments have to be open-minded'; otherwise, the Song Remains the Same.

  • Gerry Chuensuksawadi

    Discussion 12 : 11/02/2009 at 11:06 PM12

    This is hundreds of them that took part in that fight, did anyone even bothered asking why they were fighting each other for? Do you even know anything about their background, lifestyle or even what they think? If not then who are you to suggest such idiotic and demeaning ideas to improve this issue, I'm saying all this because obviously you people who are commenting or suggesting ideas that sounds more a joke to them don't have a clue or care much about what happens to them, for all the people care they could dead or in hospital because of this. People who've made suggestions such as closure of the institutions, merging the two institutions or even putting a ban of some sort won't fully stop these eruptions from happening, this is young peoples lives on the line as well as others around. Until we ask those questions, learn really whats going on and devise a real plan into tackling the situation then there won't be an end to it, and more and more ignorant people like the names mentioned will continue to make stupid comments and treat this as though its not such a real problem.

  • Thai Loverupl

    Discussion 11 : 11/02/2009 at 10:29 PM11

    SLACCP!

    Is it a truth that Thailand is or should be governed by large number of middle class of Bangkok or should be govern by large number of lower class of Thai people in Thailand land? Are you saying only the people (of course elite one in bangkok) are smart and rest of the thai people are mindless? If yest ... you are a crap ... Goto hell!!

  • bswangjaeng

    Discussion 10 : 11/02/2009 at 06:26 PM10

    Discussion #6.

    Will you please go to bed and stop with your PAR RED SHIRT BS.

    And, if you really want to go that path, what about the red shirts (taxsin paid thugs. led by brainless inept people like jakrabop who doesn't know what day of the week it is) who recently burst into a temple and roughed up some monks.

    How about the taking over of the Government House, The airports, NBT on and on, by the way PAD is not new they and their leaders have been at this for some years also so the students could have learned alot over the years, How about the 70's, 80's. You just amaze me on there lack of history.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top