| about this site | who we are | site map | reading tips | teaching tips | student tips | build vocab |
| teaching vocab | hot links | visit Thai school | Bangkok Post | student weekly | home

July 31, 2007

Homeschooling spells freedom

Not being tied to a set curriculum that is only taught during regular school hours in a distant classroom which, in turn, is only open during fixed school terms, grants a world of flexibility and opportunities to families who participate in a homeschool program

Story and photos by WEENA NOPPAKUNTHONG

Chadaporn Wee, a Danish company manager in Laem Chabang, and her Singaporean husband, are disgruntled by Thailand's secondary school system and chose to homeschool their son following his completion of Grade 6 in a Thai school.

Chadaporn says the Thai tradition of paying tea money and the schools' admissions process that selects students based solely on the highest test scores offends her. She also thinks the fees of international schools are too costly.

What is homeschooling?

Homeschooling is the education of children in their home, rather than in a public or private school or other facility outside the child's home. A parent, other family members or guardians usually provide the educational instructions.

Today, homeschooling may seem strange to some and is probably not understood by even the most educated. But before the introduction of compulsory school attendance laws in the 1800's, most childhood education throughout the world occurred within the family or local community. Only a small portion of the population attended schools or employed tutors, as most parents could not afford private schools and most governments had not yet assumed the responsibility to provide free public education.

In Thailand today, homeschooling is a viable option for parents who wish to provide their children a quality education or a social environment that the parents believe is not possible to attain in formal schools.

Reasons to homeschool

Chummas helps Poon read an English book on dinosaurs, one of his favorite topics.

Thai and foreign parents opt for homeschooling for various other reasons, including their child's gifted intelligence or religious orientation, a child's ill health or anti-social temperament, or even because of traffic congestion caused by long commutes to and from school during rush hour.

Chummas Panghom, 45, resigned as a college teacher to homeschool her son. She and her lawyer-husband committed to homeschool their only child before he turned three because, ``The school system cannot give him the education that caters to his nature.''

The Panghoms believe that learning should take place anywhere and all the time, not just during school hours or within the narrow confines of a traditional classroom. For these and other reasons, Chummas and her husband rejected formal schooling for their son Maswat, who prefers his nickname ``Poon''.

Contrary to the usual stereotype that homeschooled children are shy, reserved and even anti-social, Poon proves the opposite. Outgoing and inquisitive, Poon respectfully grabbed me by my wrist to show me another part of the home, as if we had been close friends for years.

Freedom to choose

The Thai Homeschooling law was endorsed by then-Education Minister Adisak Bodharamik and became efffective on July 14, 2004. The law recognizes that it is the inherent right of parents to determine the direction and quality of their child's education.

Chummas likes the fact that the ministry allows homeschooling parents the freedom and flexibility to adjust their days, times and places of teaching according to a child's needs and interests.

Chadaporn — who homeschools her elder son, Paul Mytri Wee, 15 — also enjoys the freedom of not having to follow the ministry's curriculum. Chadaporn employs a British, private tutor to teach Paul a range of subjects to prepare him for the International General Certificate of Secondary Education (IGCSE) examination because the family's ultimate goal is for Paul to pursue his college degree abroad.

Unlike Chummas, Chadaporn has never registered herself or her son as participants in the homeschool program. Therefore, Paul will not have a formal diploma to evidence the completion of his secondary education. But Chadaporn says the IGCSE exam results will be sufficient for college admission.

Learner-centered curriculum

Chummas takes advantage of her freedom to choose and has designed a curriculum that focuses on her son's athletic interests. She avoids rigid preset curricula. From an early age, Poon enjoys athletic activities and is always running, Chummas says. Accordingly, she exposes Poon to his favorite sports. He has swimming lessons every weekday for two hours because he likes it and excels at it.

``I like horseback riding and swimming. I want to be an athlete. My mom will help make me a basketball player, a jockey, a swimmer and even a national athlete,'' confirms Poon.

When asked if he wants to be the next Paradorn Srichapan, Poon smiles broadly and says, ``Yes, if I can go that far.''

Chummas and her husband realize that Poon's education can not be limited to sports and things he wants, so she integrates mathematics, biology, language, ethics, social skills and manners into Poon's specialized curriculum.

Poon's frequent exposure to nature at his grandparents' orchards outside Bangkok has made him keen on environmental science. By observing and recording notes in his science diary about the growth of a red bean seed in his backyard, for example, Poon practices several skills at once: writing, spelling, mathematics and scientific methodology.

Clear path ahead

Santor, or 'Fang', Chalermchai is reserved but gets excited when he talks about his homeschooling and dreams of becoming a conductor.

``Fang'' or Santor Chalermchai is 19 years old and a second-year student at Mahidol University's College of Music. He was homeschooled for three years following his primary school.

``Homeschooling makes my interests clearer and more defined,'' says Fang, referring to his interest in music, which has greatly expanded since he first joined his primary school band. Fang says his parents' strong support for him to study what interests him, makes him want to constantly learn new things.

While he was being homeschooled, he learned classical guitar and music theory on Sundays at the Royal Thai Navy School of Music. He's currently pursuing classical guitar studies at Mahidol, but aspires to study conducting in China with the financial support of a scholarship.

Like Poon, Fang is on a clear and determined path to achieving his goals, but not all homeschoolers are this fortunate.

Limited social circle

A common assumption about children who are homeschooled is that they are deprived of a proper social life and the opportunity to freely interact with peers who are not members of their immediately family. Children learn from simply interacting with other children. They learn even more when they interact with children who come from a different way of life, a different religion, and a different socio-economic background.

Chummas acknowledges that her son might not have many friends his own age, but his social circle reflects reality, and his friends are of various ages, she says.

Chummas is also the secretary of the Thai Homeschool Association, a voluntary support group that helps families survive the rigors of homeschooling. So she fully understands the importance of regular peer group interaction among youngsters.

Paul's mother is concerned also about her son's limited social circle, which consists only of his primary school friends. She is also concerned about depriving him of developing his intersocial and dating skills during his adolescent years, when it is natural to develop an attraction to the opposite sex. She consoles herself by the fact that her son will be exposed to plenty of girls once he enters college.

Chummas interjects that Poon easily makes friends with other children during their swimming lessons, so he is not totally cut off from making friends on his own.

Recalling the fun activities he participated in and the friendships he made during high school and reflecting on the importance of adolescent life, Fang adds that, ``It's the part of your life that it would be a pity to miss out on.''

When Fang returned to the formal school system, he says he felt equipped academically because the curriculum in his music faculty did not require very demanding academic subjects. Still, it took Fang several weeks to adjust socially and to begin making new friends, he says. He explained that at first he was perceived as being arrogant due to his serious attitude in class. He doesn't blame homeschooling though.

Sitting for government tests

Homeschoolers are required to take the national examinations, just like students who attend formal schools, and must test at Grades 3, 6, 9 and 12. Poon recently sat for the Grade 3 exam. Science, at 50 percent, was his highest score among all the subjects. Chummas admits that she failed to expose Poon to practice tests and testing techniques prior to the exam. ``He needs to develop the skills to demonstrate his knowledge'' to the examiner, she says.

Unlike Poon, since Paul is not registered with the ministry, he does not take government tests. His tutor instead gives him regular exams and exposes him to sample IGCSE exams.

Rights and benefits

To register as a homeschool in Thailand, the Education Service Area Office requires that the teacher or parent has completed a minimum education of Grade 12 or pass the evaluation by the Education Service Area Office. Once the Area office is satisfied, it will issue certificates to the student and parents under the Education Ministry that can be used as authorization to pursue further studies or to apply for a job.

Benefits from formally registering as a homeschool in Thailand include tax advantages for parents, value added tax exemptions for school supplies and equipment, which Chadaporn advises are very expensive. She says some English textbooks Paul uses cost as much as 5,000-6,000 baht each.

Registered parents also receive state subsidies for their child's education, the same as students who attend formal schools, only the money goes directly to the parents instead of to the school.

Lack of public awareness

Chummas says many Thais are still very uninformed about homeschooling. Very few people know that the Education Ministry has issued regulations that govern homeschooling, she says. Chadaporn agrees, while freely admitting that even she does not know some benefits of registering as a homeschool under the ministry.

Society's ignorance prevents Poon from participating in some activities simply because he is not affiliated with a public or private school. Organizations seem to fear that since Poon does not attend a formal school he will exhibit disruptive or inappropriate behavior.

Similarly, Chadaporn says Paul is barred from participation in ROTC because he is not currently in an established school.

Motherly advice

For parents interested in homeschooling their children, Chummas warns that it is a daunting task, which demands parents to regularly keep track of all learning activities and lessons, and to always seek new avenues of knowledge for your child. These tasks, she emphasizes, do not stop when the child reaches age 16 and assumes greater independent study.

Chadaporn adds that it is crucial for both parents to agree on the decision to homeschool their child because it affects their child's future and the whole family. She suggests that parents conduct thorough research into homeschooling before making a final decision, but stay focused on what college their child plans to attend.

She warns that parents need to be confident in their decision so as to resist pressure from friends and relatives who may worry that homeschooling will result in a substandard education.

PROs and CONs

There are some downsides to homeschooling.

  • Critics of homeschooling say that homeschooling lacks essential social interaction with other children of a similar age but dissimilar socio-economic-religious backgrounds. Being around people that are different teaches students tolerance, patience, fair play and forgiveness, as well as simple things, such as learning to share the same toy, to take turns, or to stand in a queue.

  • Others think that having more than one teacher is beneficial, whereas in most homeschooling scenarios it is only the mother who is responsible for teaching the child. Contrast that with formal schooling, which affords a child from 12 to 30 teachers by the time he or she graduates from high school.

  • Critics contend many homeschoolers grow up to be social misfits with no vibrancy in their personality and who in later life are generally rejected by the opposite sex as being dull and boring.

    There are, of course, many positive aspects of homeschooling.

  • First, there is the tremendous freedom to study any time, any place and any where, and not be anchored to a rigid schedule or routine.

  • Homeschooled kids tend to do well academically during and after home schooling and on standardized tests.

  • Homeschooling affords the child precious additional time to bond and to develop emotional ties with his parents during a critical stage in his young life. It is thought that the extra time the parent-teacher and child have to bond produces long term results that can not be replaced by a formal school.

  • Curricula can be customized for each child, allowing him or her to do things that interest or motivate them or that are deemed important by the family.

  • Homeschoolers tend to become lifelong learners because they never acquired the bad habit of learning only while ``in the classroom''. Instead, they learn any time and any place, including weekends and during holidays for regular school. They carry these habits into later life.

  • Homeschooled children and their parents can go on vacation anytime; and are more apt to make vacation educational.

  • There is virtually no `lost time' with homeschooling, no two-hour commutes to and from school, and no uniforms to buy.

  • Education is more efficient because difficult lessons get more time and easy lessons get finished faster.

    Caveats

    A few things don't fit neatly under Pros or Cons, but they are no less important.

  • Proper homeschooling takes a lot of time, energy and long-term dedication by the parent(s). At first, the strain is heavy but it does get easier over time.

  • Homeschooling works best when parents are part of a community or other support groups that are also involved in homeschooling. This provides support for the parent-teacher and important social interaction opportunities for the child.

  • Home teachers must quickly master the art of being a facilitator, not a lecturer, and must refrain from doing the work or activity for the child. The focus must at all times be on the child's education, not the parent's.

  • Children must be encouraged to have a pro-active role in planning their own education and activities.

  • Finally, after parents register with the ministry, officials will visit the homeschool once annually to assess and evaluate the student's education and learning environment.

  • Parents must also submit an annual report on what has been taught and students must sit the national assessment exams for Grades 3, 6, 9 and 12.
  • Read our other cover stories here.

    Back to our home page

    |? The Post Publishing Public Co., Ltd.
    All rights reserved 2007
    |
    Last modified: July 27, 2007