| about this site | who we are | site map | reading tips | teaching tips | student tips | build vocab |
| teaching vocab | hot links | visit Thai school | Bangkok Post | student weekly | home

This column is for self
study or classroom use and gives guided help with reading the wide variety of writing styles and topics that appear as feature articles in the Bangkok Post. The lessons include background information, skill
building practice and vocabulary explanations.
April 3, 2007
 

Original ideas?

INTRODUCTION
How would you feel if someone copied the format of your success? Would it make you feel proud or annoyed?

As with most successful movies or books, there is just a matter of time before someone comes along and more or less re-writes the original story. At times, the stories are too close to the original and accusations of plagiarism are raised. Other times, the writer manages to keep enough distance from the original, and can ride the success of the first one. The book review of today belongs to the latter category.

Novelist Steve Barry has obviously been influenced by Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code, but he is far from the only one. A multitude of novels dealing with ancient secret societies, and mixing fact with fiction, have been published since The Da Vinci Code. However, in the world of literature, there is never a completely original idea. The concept of complete originality doesn't even exist - for natural reasons; all novels written are implicitly or explicitly influenced by earlier works. But, as with The Alexandria Link, this doesn't necessarily lessen the quality of the book. Why not read it and find out for yourself?

plagiarism
to use another person's idea or a part of their work and pretend that it is your own

latter
the second of two things that have just been mentioned

multitude
very many

concept
an idea or principle

originality
the quality of being interesting and different from everyone or everything else

implicitly
suggested but not stated directly

explicitly
stated directly



OUR STORY FROM THE BANGKOK POST

The Promised Land?

Reviewed by BERNARD TRINK

The Alexandria Link
Steve Berry
465 pages, 2007, Hodder & Stoughton, paperback.
Available at Asia Books and leading book stores, 595 baht.


Dan Brown's premise in The Da Vinci Code, that Jesus wasn't the son of God and didn't ascend to heaven after his crucifixion but went on to marry and sire children, was greeted with derision by the Vatican and failed in its intention to shake the Christian Church to its foundations. But because the book is a bonanza, other authors have copied its format of secret codes, ancient and recent, clues in obscure churches, societies, etc.

Steve Berry, another Yank, has penned a novel with a premise every bit as startling. According to The Alexandria Link, the Old Testament as we know it is not the Old Testament written in the long forgotten Old Hebrew. Centuries passed before the Old Testament was published in latter-day Hebrew, with extensive revisions. The major one was that the Holy Land God promised Abraham wasn't in Palestine, but in western Arabia.

The author, through several important characters in The Alexandria Link, argues that apart from the latter Hebrew Old Testament, there is no historical proof that the significant events therein ever happened: not the parting of the Red Sea; not the David and Goliath encounter; not the greatness under Solomon, et al. Archaeological digs (forbidden in Saudi Arabia) unearthed not a trace of any of this.

Berry quotes authors who assert that there are areas in western Arabia that approach descriptions in the Old Testament that Canaan doesn't. Doubtless this will be scoffed at by Talmudic scholars in Jerusalem. They in turn will demand historical proof. The issue is a vital one. If Israel isn't the Promised Land, why are the Zionists fighting so hard for it? Then again, if the Promised Land is near Mecca, won't the Arab world turn on the Saudis?

Mixing fact and fiction, lawyer and well-traveled Berry raises the possibility that the Library of Alexandria, the storehouse of learning of the ancient world, razed by the Muslims, wasn't entirely destroyed. More than a few of its half-million manuscripts were rescued from the conflagration and moved to a place known only to Guardians. Among them could be at least one copy of the Old Testament in Old Hebrew, which might yet be translated.

Apprehensive as to what it might say, the Israelis don't want the hiding place found. As their allies, neither do the Americans. Nor the Saudis. But the Islamist jihadists would pay any amount for it; and there are unscrupulous Westerners after it, with the intention of selling the location to the highest bidder. How the various sides go about it is the main plot of this story. The minor plot is of a conspiracy in high places to kill the Israeli-friendly US President, so that his successor will tilt toward the oil-rich Arabs.

There are shootouts, kidnappings, bombs going off, so many that at times we're not sure who's doing what. My favourite line is: ''I'm not a murderer, just an assassin.''

Reading The Alexandria Link, this reviewer wonders who wrote the 10 Commandments.

premise
an idea used to support another theory

ascend
to move up or to a higher position

sire
to become the father of a child

derision
when someone or something is laughed at and considered ridiculous or of no value

bonanza
a situation from which large profits are made

obscure
not known to many people

Yank
American

startling
surprising and sometimes worrying

revisions
changes of something

archaeological
the study of ancient cultures by looking for and examining their buildings, tools, and other objects

unearthed
found something in the ground

trace
proof that someone or something was in a place

assert
to say that something is certainly true

doubtless
used to mean that you are certain that something will happen or is true

scoffed
laughed and spoke about a person or idea in a way which shows that you think they are stupid or ridiculous

Talmudic scholars
people who study, especially at a university, the collection of ancient Jewish laws and tradition for religious and social matters

vital
necessary for the success or continued existence of something; extremely important

the Promised Land
in the Bible, the land of Canaan, promised by God to Abraham and his race

Zionists
the people of a political movement which had as its original aim the creation of a country for Jewish people, and which now works to help the development of Israel

razed
completely destroyed a city, building, etc

conflagration
a large destructive fire

apprehensive
feeling anxious about something that you are going to do

jihadists
people who fight a holy war against people who are a threat to the Islamic religion or who oppose its teachings

unscrupulous
behaving in a way that is dishonest or unfair in order to get what you want

bidder
a person who offers money for something

conspiracy
when people secretly plan together to do something bad or illegal

tilt
to be more favorable for a particular situation to happen or a particular decision to be made when other situations or decisions are possible

the Ten Commandments
in the Bible, the rules given to Moses by God on Mount Sinai


Read our other instant lesson here.

Return to our home page.

| ? The Post Publishing Public Co., Ltd.
All rights reserved 2007
|
Last modified: April 2, 2007