Profit margins probed as govt considers tutorial school taxes | Bangkok Post: learning

Learning > Education Features

Profit margins probed as govt considers tutorial school taxes

Education officials are looking into concerns over tutorial schools overcharging parents and students.

IT ALL ADDS UP: Tutorial schools’ profit margins must not exceed 20% of their total operating costs, under the 2007 Private School Act.

Chanwit Tubsuphan, secretary-general of the Office of the Private Education Commission (Opec) overseeing tutorial school operations, said under the 2007 Private School Act, the profit margins of non-formal education outlets registered with the Education Ministry must not not exceed 20% of their operating costs.

Tutorial schools exceeding this profit ceiling would face a closure order, Mr Chanwit said.

However, the law covers only tutorial schools registered with the Education Ministry. Those that are unregistered _ which are not allowed to use the word "school" in their name _ always reap profits from students, he said.

The issue surfaced last week when the National Anti-Corruption Commission proposed that the cabinet tax tutorial schools, which they said earned several billions baht of annual revenue.

The cabinet has ordered more studies into the proposed taxation before going ahead with the scheme.

Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva said he disagreed with the taxation idea. Tutorial schools are regarded as business establishments, but they provide education, which is why the business tax has been waived, he said.

The premier added that the important issue was to find out if the schools were overcharging with their fees.

Sahattaya Sukhasvasti Na Ayudhaya, a mother of two, said she paid tens of thousands of baht each year for her sons' tutorial school fees.

Mrs Sahattaya said she was afraid that the tutorial school operators would pass on the burden to parents by increasing fees if they were taxed.

"I'm ready to pay for the tuition cost if it helps my sons perform better in their studies, but the cost should not be too high," she said.

Chitra Chantrakul, president of the Association of Private School Administrator for Non-formal Education, said non-formal education establishments had to shoulder heavy operating costs without any government subsidy.

"The public thinks that tutorial schools make a huge profit, but in fact they have a lot of expenditures," she said.

Non-formal education outlets would hold a meeting to discuss the taxation issue on Friday.

Did you know?

You can introduce your kids to edutainment reading with our Student Weekly magazine: Thailand's only all-English entertainment and education magazine for teens and all ages.

About the author

columnist
Writer: Lamphai Intathep
Position: Reporter

Your comments

  • Discussion 2 : 16/01/2011 at 09:24 AM2

    Actually the business tax is not much of an issue.

    In Thailand, the business profits tax becomes a tax credit when the profit is distributed to shareholders (owners).

    For example, Company A made 100 baht profit last year and paid the 30% business profits tax.

    They had a net profit after tax of 70 THB.

    This year they pay a dividend to the owner of 70 THB.

    The owner will show 100 THB of income and a 30 THB pre-paid tax credit on his income tax return related to this income at the end of the year.

    The actual amount of tax paid then depends on how much total income the owner has.

    Thus, the business profits tax can defer the taxes, but does not change the amount of tax collected.

    This is very, very different than the business profits tax in the United States.

    When we pay that, we wave "Bye-Bye" and it is gone.

    In compensation for that, dividends are then generally, but not completely, taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income.

  • Discussion 1 : 16/01/2011 at 08:47 AM1

    Stop wasting money on these exploitative tutorial schools. Invest in proper schools and get rid of the useless teachers.

Reply

Sign in once and access every part of the website at your convenience!

Please log in to our Bangkokpost.com community to post your comment.
You can sign in to the community by clicking here.

If you are not part of the community yet, please sign up here. By being part of this community you will get all these privileges.