Booze ban 'will harm tourism'

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

News » Local News

Booze ban 'will harm tourism'

  • Published: 19/03/2009 at 12:00 AM
  • Newspaper section: News

Plans to ban the sale of alcohol during the Songkran festival have sparked a bitter row between the Tourism and Sports and the Public Health ministries.

Tourism and Sports Minister Chumpol Silpa-archa yesterday opposed the Public Health Ministry's plan to ban the sales, saying it would harm the already crippled tourism industry.

Anti-alcohol protesters demand a Songkran booze ban. APICHIT JINAKUL

But Deputy Public Health Minister Manit Nopamornbode insisted a survey conducted by his ministry had found that most tourists do not consider drinking to be the main purpose of their visit. They prefer to enjoy the culture and visit tourist destinations.

The Public Health Ministry has proposed two options on the ban.

One calls for a halt to alcohol sales altogether from midnight April 11 to midnight April 14. The other softer option is to allow licensed restaurants and entertainment venues to serve alcohol from 6pm to midnight during the three-day period.

The National Committee on Alcohol Policy will choose which, if any, of the two options to adopt.

Mr Chumpol said the government should delay the ban on alcohol sales during Songkran until at least next year.

He said the government needed additional tourism revenues to substitute the sharp drop in earnings from exports and investment.

The minister said the tourism industry had the capacity to recover from the economic crisis much faster than other sectors and could serve as the driving force to support the overall economy.

His stand mirrored that of Deputy Prime Minister Sanan Kajornprasart.

Maj-Gen Sanan, who is the chairman of the National Committee on Alcohol Policy, said the ban would not address the root cause of drink driving and the high incidence of road accidents during the Songkran holiday.

He said most accidents over Songkran happened on small provincial roads, not on main roads. The authorities need to strictly enforce the law on those accident-prone areas.

Maj-Gen Sanan said the ban was expected to affect international tourists' travel plans and could hurt the country's tourism earnings. A study on the impact of a ban on alcohol sales should be carried out before it is imposed.

A ban might encourage consumers to stock up on drink before the holidays, which would do nothing to help reduce the road accident rate.

Maj-Gen Sanan said his statements reflected his personal view, not that of his committee.

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • Jimmy

    Discussion 31 : 19/03/2009 at 10:51 PM31

    All western tourists may not have drinking alcahol as top of there list when they visit Thailand, many will, but what they do expect is choice, if they want to have a drink they should be able to have one,they can go anywhere in the world and spend there hard earned cash.Thailand should do more to improve driving standards, motorbikes on sidewalks!!! corrupt police taking money from drunkan drivers instaed of arresting them.Why punish the people who want to drink and have fun, punish the people who drink and drive and corrupt police

  • mike williams in Bangkok

    Discussion 30 : 19/03/2009 at 06:05 PM30

    Suku 3-10pm
    You doubt that it will affect the tourist numbers,I will assure you that it will decimate them but have no effect on the problem of Thais drinking and driving because like me they will just stock up before the ban starts.
    Read the comment by Vanaarde at 1208 to understand how tourists will view this ban.
    Here is a better suggestion of lateral thinking, allow the sale of alcohol to tourists on production of a foreign passport, problem solved and tourists not affected.

  • roy.

    Discussion 29 : 19/03/2009 at 05:34 PM29

    As usual the only places where this ban will be totally honoured are the conspicuous tourist areas. Thus tourism will be discouraged.

    Most Thais will know where (shop or bar etc.) the rules will not be adherred to.

    Most visitors with some experience will know where to buy alcohol.

    I think Thai politicians are intellectually bereft.

    The road deaths toll at Songkran is hideous.

    Surely this matter should have been solved years ago by increased traffic vigilance.

    Yet we now have this knee-jerk reaction addressing the problem from the bottom upwards.

  • EQsan

    Discussion 28 : 19/03/2009 at 04:16 PM28

    simply stock-up...

  • Mickyfin

    Discussion 27 : 19/03/2009 at 04:04 PM27

    More self destruction from the thai government? At least the hotels in pattaya would be cheaper because the average tourist will be changing their destination!

  • Mod

    Discussion 26 : 19/03/2009 at 03:53 PM26

    Only a severe alcoholic would say they're going somewhere just for the drinks. Thailand is not particularly known for its alcoholic drinks, so it's not people main purpose in coming to Thailand. They're here for the culture, shows, girls, ect..but they will drink as well in the process. Taking that away will keep them away!

    BTW would anyone say in a survey that they're going to Thailand for the drinks? (even if they do drink?), I DON'T THINK SO!

  • bob

    Discussion 25 : 19/03/2009 at 03:44 PM25

    Tourism is already destroyed by the blood red shirted warriors of thug Thaksin demonstrating. throwing bottles, eggs and burning effigies on the streets of Thailand. Seems to be like Pakistan to me.
    I wonder who will win this one.??

  • Nat, I'm Thai

    Discussion 24 : 19/03/2009 at 03:38 PM24

    Guys, i'm Thai. After i've heard about this news, i thought that it's impossible to do such this things. I'm sure that most of Thai people disagree w/ this campaing bcoz we know that some drivers, they do not fear to drive when they drink bcoz the law is not servere for the drink driver in my country. And if u drive and pass some check point, you will see the volunteers and some officers who sat and drunk alcohol together. Who's gonna follow the law if these people will keep doing this even they are on duty... Right! we should have a servere penalty for the drink driver such as some countries did, for example, stop driving for a year or fine or ... they can do many things for society. I love my country and we always welcome everyone to be our guests. But this is incorrect...So we're waiting for the result......Thanks

  • Suku

    Discussion 23 : 19/03/2009 at 03:10 PM23

    Hi..let us not over-react in commenting/cricising..there will be no drop in tourism (do you have info, of what percentage of tourists consume alcohol, or what is the income from alcohol sales in the overall tourist revenues ?) The measure is not aimed at tourists, so their requirements will not get affected..!! believe it or not ! Even now, we have alcohol is not sold from Noon to 5 Pm, but this does not affect the service, it is served in restaurants. This measure is important to save the lives of those persons who over-drink, drive and die in accidents.. Responsible drinkers can plan their purchases based on their consumption. The measure is aimed at erratic and unplanned consumption, in the festive moods..! All possible measures have been tried and failed, save this. So, let us be optimistic, positive and let it be implemented.

  • Oliver

    Discussion 22 : 19/03/2009 at 02:16 PM22

    guys your country looks like a Muslim country when it come to religion celebration.
    While christian are supposed to eat fish on friday no country ban the sell of meat on that day! It's called tolerance, where everyone is free to make its own choice. Don't impose stupid laws to visitors in your country who are going to spend money during there stay.
    I assume that the regular Police after hour clubs will be serving Alcohol without worrying while the legal ones won't be able.

    Serious tourist not drinking during their stay? You got to be kidding Sukhumvit bars/disco are pack of tourists.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top