Plan to ban alcohol sales for Songkran gets canned

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

News » Local News

Plan to ban alcohol sales for Songkran gets canned

  • Published: 30/03/2009 at 04:08 PM
  • Online news:

Plans to ban the sale of alcohol during next month's Songkran festival have been scrapped.

Authorities fear a ban will harm the already damaged tourism industry.

The National Committee for Alcohol Consumption Control yesterday said there would be no alcohol ban during the traditional new year from April 13 to 15.

Instead it had opted to launch an intensive campaign against drink-driving.

The committee, chaired by Deputy Prime Minister Sanan Kachornprasart, decided a ban on alcohol sales during Songkran would further harm the tourism industry.

The resolution was reached after a two-hour meeting with relevant agencies. Attending the meeting were Tourism and Sports Minister Chumpol Silpa-archa, Justice Minister Pirapan Salirathavibhaga, Social Development and Human Security Minister Issara Somchai, Deputy Interior Minister Boonjong Wongtrairat, Deputy Public Health Minister Manit Nopamornbode and Deputy Education Minister Narisara Chawaltanpipat.

Maj Gen Sanan said the meeting agreed to issue a Prime Minister's Office regulation officially prohibiting the sale of alcohol on important Buddhist holidays. He said this was a gift to the Thai people.

The religious days include Makha Bucha, Visakha Bucha, Asalaha Bucha and Khao Pansa, or Buddhist Lent.

He said agencies would launch an anti-alcohol campaign over Songkran covering drinking while driving and drinking when celebrating Songkran on the back of pick-up trucks.

He said the sale of alcohol over the Songkran holiday would be in line with existing regulations, which limits sales to between 11am and 2pm and between 5pm and midnight.

"The meeting decided the ban would have more of an impact on tourism, particularly on Songkran day, which draws over 80,000 foreign tourists," Maj Gen Sanan said.

"An alcohol ban, if imposed, would drive away foreign tourists."

The deputy premier was also concerned about increased sales of illegal liquor if a ban was imposed.

He rejected the results of surveys which indicated people believed a decision not to impose a ban showed the government was under the thumb of breweries and distillers.

His committee was more concerned about the impact on tourism and problems regarding the sale of illegal liquor.

The panel's resolution will spark protests from people in some areas.

Deputy Public Health Minister Manit said his ministry - which proposed the alcohol ban - would not be discouraged by the committee's resolution.

Its efforts to campaign against alcohol would not go to waste, he said.

The ministry would push for the issue of a PM's Office regulation to prohibit the consumption of alcohol in public areas during the festival.

Kamron Choodecha, coordinator of the Alcohol Watch Network, lashed out at the Sanan panel for rejecting a ban.

He said the panel was being insensitive as it could easily impose measures to reduce deaths and injuries.




EARLIER REPORT by Bangkokpost.com

The National Committee on Alcohol Consumption Control has rejected the proposal to prohibit the sale of alcoholic beverages during next month's Songkran festival, fearing a ban may hurt the economy and the tourist industry.

The committee meeting, chaired by Deputy Prime Minister Sanan Kajornprasart,  on Monday 
agreed to allow alcoholic drinks to be sold during Songkran, which is the Thai New Year celebration.

However, alcohbol sales will be banned on national religious holidays, including Visakha Bucha, Makha Bucha, Asarnha Bucha and Buddhist Lent days.

Maj-Gen Sanan said the committee took the economy and tourism industry into consideration.

There was also the rationale that a ban on legal sales of alcohol would not stop people drinking illicitly distilled liquor. If anything, sales of moonshine would increase.

However, the committee would call meetings with provincial governors and senior police nationwide to insist on stricter campaigns against consumption of alcohol and drunk driving.

Monday's meeting of the booze policy panel was moved to the Ministry of Tourism and Sports because of the United Front for Democracy against Dictatorship (UDD) protest around Government House.

The Public Health Ministry had reommended a  total ban on sales of alcoholic bevereges from April 12 to 14 inclusive, or restricting sales to only licensed restaurants, bars, cafes and pubs from 6pm to midnight.

The proposal was driven by increasing concern over the rising road toll during the annual holiday. The most death and injury involves young people in the  provinces getting drunk and riding motorcycles.

About the author

Writer: BangkokPost.com

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • djheikkil.com

    Discussion 17 : 03/06/2009 at 11:28 AM17

    The real problem is attitude. Here in Thailand there are no accidents, it is all 'God's will' so it doesn't matter if they drink or run a red light or drive too quickly, if it's 'God's will' that they crash, it's GOING TO HAPPEN, regardless of what they do...

  • Wombat

    Discussion 16 : 31/03/2009 at 06:39 PM16

    Common sense has indeed prevailed.
    The real issue is not the availability or non-availability of alcohol during Songkran nor the 'threat' of tourists being driven away.

    The reality is that too many drivers and riders are totally irresponsible. They happen to be mostly Thai.

    Banning alcohol would be akin to banning vehicles. Neither addresses the real problem, which is more to do with Thai attitudes towards driving/riding and their behaviour con the roads, not only during Songkran but throughout the year.

    The other reality is that Thai police are so irresponsible.

    Improve driving/riding attitudes and enforce the laws consistently and rigorously. This will take decades because even school children have inherited the 'mai phen rai' attitude to road behaviour and police apathy is endemic.

    So, good luck Thailand.

  • Wombat

    Discussion 15 : 31/03/2009 at 02:18 PM15

    I agree with you Jay; it is very sad that so many people die on the roads during Songkran (and throughout the year). Teaching drivers and riders to be more responsible for their own actions, enforcing the laws that exist and perhaps shortening the Songkran chaos may help.
    Basically, I believe it is irresponsibility that is the killer. The classic 'mai phen rai' attitude is not always a positive one.

  • Ted

    Discussion 14 : 31/03/2009 at 02:02 PM14

    The term 'Amazing Thailand' could not be more appropiate.As some other writers stated, the police should be doing their job all year round. The government seems to always come up with knee jerk solutions, instead of addressing the lack of policing all year. My observations where I live in Surat Thani is there is no policing of the traffic rules at all. The number of young children riding motor cycles and the riding and driving habits of a large percentage is appalling. Go to Patong and the police stop any tourist without a helmut and give them a 500 baht fine. They also do licence checks. Thailand has the highest number of road fatalities per population in the world. Unless the attitude of the people changes and there is at least some resemblance of policing, it will only deteriorate further.

  • taakaa

    Discussion 13 : 31/03/2009 at 11:12 AM13

    Government should to protected from cause not results.

  • Paul

    Discussion 12 : 31/03/2009 at 11:09 AM12

    I think it is absurd to state that tourism would be affected by banning alcohol during Songkran. Sure some people may not come because they see Songkran as a time to get as drunk as possible and partake in a nation wide water fight...but what about the Thai people? Would they stop drinking and abide by the new ban? I think not!

    Anyone who knows about the ban can go and buy as much alcohol as they want before the holiday anyway. Furthermore, many small shops would continue to sell alcohol no matter what. Even the laws that have been imposed on buying alcohol between 11am until 2pm and 5pm until midnight cannot even be properly policed. How would they enforce this ban?

    What they need to concentrate on is educating people on drunk driving and enforcing the law! Set up check points and actually have enough of a police presence to do something about it. And don't just enforce them during the holidays...do it year round. The annual death toll caused by traffic accidents is high in Thailand because so many normal traffic laws go unenforced. What the government and police should concentrate on is the amount of people in each vehicle, new seatbelt regulations, and yes...drunk drivers!

    In Thailand, it is only mandatory for people in the front two seats of the vehicle to actually wear a seatbelt and it is common to see a pick up truck with twenty or more people sandwiched in the back! How does allowing these obvious safety risks go without penalty? If they want the death toll to drop during the holiday they should begin by enforcing regular traffic laws throughout the year, not just during Songkran.

    If you told tourists planning on coming to Thailand during the holiday that they would not be allowed to buy alcohol on the street corner, but they could buy alcohol at a restaurant or nightclub, they would say "So what!" Some tourist would not obligue the ban because neither would Thai people. Banning alcohol during religious holidays shows respect and is mostly upheld by the everyday Thai person. Banning alcohol during the Thai new year would make alot of people angry and wouldn't solve anything. People will drink... and people will drive. Let's just hope they're smart enough to not do both!

  • jay

    Discussion 11 : 31/03/2009 at 10:59 AM11

    if everyone doesn't pay any attention how to save their life during songkarn fastival,almost of travelers would die by road accident and drink and drive.

    i feel unhappy if very year would be expected enormous a mount of died body.

  • Lertsiri Boonmee

    Discussion 10 : 31/03/2009 at 10:35 AM10

    This is a silly reason to scrap the ban. Sure booze is good for business. But didn't we just see a campaign where the comercial told the public that GIVING BOOZE to another as a GIFT is like sending them to HELL?

    This article also mentions that this situation is like a GIFT TO THE THAI PEOPLE.....

    CASE CLOSED.

    I guess the ad campaigns were just a way to waste money instead they could have used that money to add more CHECK POINTS on the STREET if they knew that the campaign was just PARSLEY sprinkled on top of a bad situation.

  • Wombat

    Discussion 9 : 31/03/2009 at 10:24 AM9

    Common sense prevails!
    Get the boys in brown to actually perform their duties; not only during Songkran but throughout the whole year.
    Lack of diligent law enforcement is one of Thailand's woes.

  • juan longpeter

    Discussion 8 : 31/03/2009 at 09:01 AM8

    I am astounded that a rational decision could be made. Driving while intoxicated is dangerous to the public. Considering that the drivers on Thailands Highways are already the worst of any country, a ban on driving private vehicles during the holidays would make more sense. Stay home and stay off the road, get drunk and be happy.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top