Charges over King's health rumours "baseless"

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

News » Local News

Charges over King's health rumours "baseless"

  • Published: 5/11/2009 at 04:55 PM
  • Online news:

An international media rights group has called for the dismissal of "baseless" charges against three people accused of spreading false rumours about His Majesty the King's health that sent stocks plunging last month.

Reporters Without Borders said on Thursday the three Thai internet users arrested in Thailand were  being mad "scapegoats" for October's drop in the market over concerns about the condition of His Majesty.

"We call for the charges against these three internet users to be dismissed," said group's statemen said.

Such accusations are baseless and violate the right to report an economic event after it has taken place. Explaining that the stock exchange fall was linked to His Majesty's health harms neither the King nor national security."

The 81-year-old monarch was admitted to hospital in mid-September with a lung infection and fever. He condition is said to have improved to the point he can stand and move with the aid of a walker.

On Sunday police arrested Katha Pajariyapong, of brokerage company KT ZMICO, and Theeranan Vipuchanin, a former executive with UBS Securities, for allegedly damaging national security by posting false information on the internet.

Somjet Sitthiworakul was then arrested on Tuesday on the same charge, under the  Computer Crimes Act. If convicted they could face up to five years in jail or a 100,000 baht fine.

Police also planned to seek a warrant in a few days for the arrest of a fourth suspect behind the spreading of the rumours.


The Thai bourse plunged 8.22 percent at one point on Oct 15 over the rumours.

Reporters without Borders said the defendants had only posted articles online that linked the fall in stocks to the fact that His Majesty was admitted to Bangkok's Siriraj Hospital on Sept 19.

The media group said Ms Theeranan pointed out that she had only translated and posted a Bloomberg News agency article written after the fall and that she was not paid to do so.

"It seems that the translation of the Bloomberg dispatch is the only piece of hard evidence in the prosecution case file," the statement said.

"The investigators have not mentioned the original article and have referred only to the translation, which reinforces the impression that the three defendants are being used as scapegoats for the fall in stocks."

Police investigators say they are still preparing the cae against the accused. from inside and outside the country.

On Wednesday, police sources said an investigator had gone abroad to gather information.

Pol Col Phisit Pao-in, deputy chief of the Economic and Cyber Crime Division, is thought to have flown to Singapore as the rumours could have been started overseas.

Pol Maj-Gen Panya Mamen, deputy chief of the Central Investigation Bureau, also said investigators would look into whether websites where the rumours were posted were directly involved in spreading the rumours.

He said the webmasters would be called for questioning and would face prosecution if they were found to have failed to stop the posting of false information causing harm to the country.

About the author

Writer: Online Reporters and AFP

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • bob

    Discussion 14 : 07/11/2009 at 09:12 PM14

    I agree entirely with the comments made by the "Reporters without Borders" organisation about a scape goat, pawns being used in this instance. This is an internationally recognised organisation made up of many respected and authoritative reporters from the worlds leading newspapers, magazines and media organisations. Their expertise is unlimited over many many years within the print trade. Somebody somewhere has done a grave injustice to these individuals and brought a great dis-service to the financial and Stock Market of Thailand. The class action case will rebound ten thousand times and the losses will be far greater than that experienced by the S.E.T. last month. They were as far as reports suggest only translating messages that were posted on the internet. The government of Thailand has no idea whatsoever about the power of these external international financial institutions. Bloomberg is one of the prime news originations that cover financial aspects world wide and their power is immense. Don't ever underestimate their integrity. They can either make or break a nation in nano seconds regarding investments. Take a look at the stock exchanges of New York, London, and Tokyo.etc. These control the stock markets of the the world in brokerage, banking, investments. Insurance and commodities.
    The stock market is a gamble like the lottery. You win some and loose some. The difference is the odds whether for or against. Many many factors influence these financial transactions and there must be some control, governance, transparency and honesty.
    On its door step this very moment Thailand has a perfect example of stock market manipulation by its own citizens of billions and billions of dollars. One of these is a fugitive on the run, ex Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawara and the other is an extradited banker Rakesh Saxena who has yet to be tried. What are the police doing or going to do with these fraudsters and embezzlers? Let’s wait and see. Their crimes are a million times greater than the so called rumours spread by these individuals using the internet.
    One should also look at the penalty for these crimes, 5 years in jail or 100,000.Bht fine. And yet if you obtain property to the value 799 million baht by illegal means you will get a two year jail sentence or abscond overseas and live in luxury by becoming a financial advisor too some third world country that relies on aid and donors to support its economy.
    I also concur with the statements made by wantmymoney Discussion number.6.

  • Jungle

    Discussion 13 : 06/11/2009 at 01:34 PM13

    That's not about money but health. How dare they stating the obvious...?

  • jingjok

    Discussion 12 : 06/11/2009 at 11:24 AM12

    "On Wednesday, police sources said an investigator had gone abroad to gather information."

    ROTFLMAO! Where'd he/she go, Hong Kong for the shopping? This is all the evidence you need that this case is without merit. It was trumped up to give some "investigator", probably a Police General, and his wife, a chance to travel at public expense.SWSFR

  • Chiangmai Skipper

    Discussion 11 : 06/11/2009 at 11:17 AM11

    Let me see if I understand this correctly. Three people have been arrested for ‘spreading ‘rumors about the Kings temporary, we pray, decline in health. The Thai authorities are attributing the temporary, we pray, fall in the market to these three people. This is absurd!

    The word “spread’ implies that something already existed, as it most certainly did in this case. To attribute the drop in the Thai stock market to these three individuals is ludicrous were it not so devastating to any concept of freedom of the press in Thailand.

    And then to stretch it to the moronic conclusion that it has damaged the country’s national security! Come on! Get a breath of fresh air, please! National security! What are the politicians doing about the on-going civil war in the south with over 3 thousand Thais killed? National security? They couldn’t even stop an invasion through the border, albeit an air-border, of Suwanabhume airport.

    Both the Thai ‘politicians of the moment’ and their Big Money Thai backers through greed and corruption have done more to damage the economy, ruin the countries reputation, and keep Thailand from the future than all the petty stories about rumor mongers and the like combined.

    Start focusing on the important things the country and its citizens need instead of trying to find a scapegoat for the drop in stocks that hurt only the rich invested Thais. Improve the dismal education system. Learn to treat the citizens as equals. Become a country with the rule of law applied evenly and equally to all. Rid the government of graft and corruption. Build a train system that is safe and something to be proud of.

    If as much time and effort were but into bettering the country as is put into political in- fighting to be top man of the political mountain to grab the wealth, there may be a chance. Better have a reality-check and get your priorities in order soon. Rumor mongers! Rumor schmongers! Get serious!

  • Vic

    Discussion 10 : 06/11/2009 at 09:53 AM10

    Thailand is obsessed with 'National Security'.
    It is used to justify whatever the men in power wants to achieve.
    In this case it also displays the level of paranoia.

  • phil

    Discussion 9 : 06/11/2009 at 07:28 AM9

    Reporters Without Borders said on Thursday the three Thai internet users arrested in Thailand were being mad "scapegoats"" There you have it, these people were acting like this because they were mad, no case to answer.

  • Somboon

    Discussion 8 : 06/11/2009 at 01:55 AM8

    Yes, Thai stock tradings, at times, were based on rumors to manipulate. I have a friend who has his companies' stocks manipulated by politicians, spreading false rumors to cause the price to go up and down to their benefits. If he did not go along, he would have been in deep troubles.

    The problem with these rumors is that it involved the monarchy, which is a no no; otherwise, it would have been nothing unusual.

  • witsawagone

    Discussion 7 : 06/11/2009 at 12:54 AM7

    It would seem that the issue should be "Who was engaged in 'short selling' versus who sold immediately after the internet article?" Short selling would indicate a PLAN to cause a drop in the market

  • wantmymoney

    Discussion 6 : 06/11/2009 at 12:03 AM6

    Another goose hunt. There have so much time on their hand to indulge in a goose chase? Why dont the solve the chronic problem facing thailand now or better still help solve the world recession or why not the climate change crisis? This is not the first time the SET has crash, it did crash when the coup took over, it stayed crashed for weeks.Why didnt the government go after the coup leaders for causing stock market to crash? Maybe this government does not understand how market economy works. Its common for stock exchanges to sell on rumours much like wall street where rumours are everyday occurance. Its a self adjusting mechanism and this is how people make money. SET has the lowest value in the whole of asia now it will get even lower, investors will not come in knowing if they sell they will be underinvestigation. Maybe next step is to go after those who sold shares on that day, jail them.

  • Joe America

    Discussion 5 : 05/11/2009 at 11:43 PM5

    As many have said before myself lets see them bring in the big fish. Then make a case against them. So simple just follow the money it leaves a trail.

    If these people are guilty of allegedly damaging national security by posting false information on the internet then many thousands more could be arrested daily. I can't see the logic. Sort of reminds me of Iran or K.G.B. policy.

    So sad for Thailand land of no more smiles only tears.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top