Cops top graft list, study finds

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

News » Local News

Cops top graft list, study finds

Of state agencies, police voted 'on the take' most

  • Published: 6/06/2009 at 12:00 AM
  • Newspaper section: News

The police force has topped the list of the most corrupt state agencies, according to a study funded by the National Anti-Corruption Commission.

The study was revealed at a two-day seminar on corruption suppression and prevention which ends today, organised by the national anti-graft agency.

NACC adviser Sirilaksana Khoman, a seminar panellist, cited a study on corruption by Saowanee Thairungroj, vice-rector at the University of the Thai Chamber of Commerce.

The NACC-commissioned study looked at the attitudes of businessmen who came into contact with state agencies and politicians.

The study showed about 40% of businessmen who had experience doing business with government agencies said the police force, including highways and traffic police officers, was the most corrupt state agency.

The top five state agencies and officers that businessmen had to pay "extra money" to during the past five months of this year were the Land Department (72.22%), followed by tambon administration organisations (68.52%), provincial administration organisations (60.52%), highways and traffic police (59.08%), and local politicians and influential figures (44.76%).

State agencies where most respondents said they experienced graft include the Customs Department (12.2%) followed by tambon administration organisations (7.8%), and the Land Department (4.8%).

About 17% of respondents said they had come into contact with corrupt politicians.

According to the study, 19% of corrupt practices in the state sector involved officials thinking up unnecessary projects, 14% involved abusing inside information for personal benefits, particularly to buy land, and about 9% was related to bid collusion.

The respondents viewed that corruption in state agencies stemmed from the culture and mindset of giving and receiving kickbacks and working environments in government agencies which are conducive to graft.

Mrs Sirilaksana said that loopholes and inefficiencies in the administration of the state sector were to blame for the endemic corruption.

"The NACC has funded many studies aimed at pointing out the causes of corruption and coming up with suggestions to close the loopholes," Mrs Sirilaksana said.

The best way to combat graft was through prevention supported by the government, NACC commissioner Methi Krongkaew said, adding that research into corruption would support the anti-graft agency's preventive measures against graft.

Speaking at the seminar, Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva stressed the need for all sectors of society, particularly young people, to play a part in monitoring and fighting graft.

He said the government wanted state agencies to adopt good governance in their organisations.

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • kngdady

    Discussion 20 : 07/06/2009 at 01:26 AM20

    Thailand do you have no shame? The country wants investments from many falang companies to do business in Thailand with all the curruption and changing laws that benefit only Thais. In America you got to jail in Thailand its a big party.

  • charlie

    Discussion 19 : 07/06/2009 at 01:01 AM19

    Corruption is so entrenched in the police that people become police in order to cash in the corruption they know they will benefit from .Why do you think someone becomes a cop in thailand ?For the salary haha.Pay a livable salary a punish corrupt police officers to the full extent of the law that they rarely enforce .

  • David

    Discussion 18 : 07/06/2009 at 12:35 AM18

    I think its basically from mentality. With lots of salary/wages doesnt gurantee they would stop the corruption but still nobody surely knows the bottom root of it.........cheers!

  • Chiangmai Skipper

    Discussion 17 : 06/06/2009 at 07:22 PM17

    I am absolutely stunned! A survey found that the police are the most corrupt! Does anybody really think that anything will ever be done to remedy or correct their illegal activity. The police have no oversight. When found to have done something criminal the entire force hunkers down and protects the "brotherhood in brown".Overlook criminal activities, drug dealing, murders of fellow Thais and westerners, chop off a fellow Thai girls arm, no problem. They can do whatever they want with total impunity. Amazing Thailand!
    Through asking and observation, it is obvious that Thais learn early on to fear the police rather than see them as the public servants they are supposed to be. Equal and fair treatment in enforcing the laws? Just another part of the "Unseen Thailand".

  • mossad

    Discussion 16 : 06/06/2009 at 05:15 PM16

    #14 - Yes, let's have another level - an independant body to investigate - which can then be bribed to let people off the hook. Sounds like it needs a few thousand staff and a big building with a silly name for starters.

  • aidinho

    Discussion 15 : 06/06/2009 at 04:46 PM15

    "The top five state agencies and officers that businessmen had to pay "extra money" to during the past five months of this year were the Land Department (72.22%), followed by tambon administration organisations (68.52%), provincial administration organisations (60.52%), highways and traffic police (59.08%), and local politicians and influential figures (44.76%)."

    What do the percentages in brackets represent?

  • Village Idiot

    Discussion 14 : 06/06/2009 at 04:36 PM14

    I disagree with GIS #11. But agree with MIKY #7.
    In my opinion, they have to start somewhere and be very severe. This somewhere surely is with the police.
    1) All policeman have to be paid a "very good" wage, in fact above average. So that they will value their job above all.

    2) Any policeman with even a 'sniff' of corruption, will be immediately suspended!and investigated. If found guilty of taking money or any other kind of corruption, he/she will be immediately dissmissed.

    3) A ruling body outside the police force will arbritrate on any complaints and their decision will be final.
    Unless this happens there will always be corruption in Thailand.
    Once the police know where they stand, they can then investigate and control the rest, businessmen, govt officials etc.
    Who dissagrees with this and why ?

  • Peter

    Discussion 13 : 06/06/2009 at 01:21 PM13

    Good to hear study and analysis is being applied to this all-pervasive problem with the conduct of financial transactions in Thailand. The problem is of epidemic proportions and needs a strong and continuing push from the top - PM Abhisit - down if it is to be seriously addressed.

    From personal experience I know under the table payments are the standard, normal, accepted manner of doing business at the local Land Office. I suspect that is just the tip of the iceberg.

    Induction training in all government agencies at state, local and national level targeted at changing the culture and mindset of people working there is one measure that is urgently needed. Many others, including strong backing from top management down and credible sanctions for errant behaviour are also necessary.

    This NACC funded study is a step in the right direction.

  • Sam

    Discussion 12 : 06/06/2009 at 01:10 PM12

    I wonder if the education system was included in the study.
    From small rural teacher up to the people in charge at the Ministry, the whole system is deplorably corrupt.
    The police or any other civil servant are merely the product of a corrupt educational system.
    Why would they be otherwise?

  • Gis

    Discussion 11 : 06/06/2009 at 01:05 PM11

    Everybody in this country knew/knows it.
    Seems to me that corruption is a part of Thai mentality. If it was'nt someone would have done something about it long time ago.

    Increasing their pay would not stop their greed.
    Someone who has 1000 000 00 Baht, wants just the one Baht more. Replace the one's who take
    Kickbacks/Teamoney. In the end we have sorted the parasites of society all out.

    Start today ! show no mercy !

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top