Cram schools shut down

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

News » Local News

Cram schools shut down

Owners seethe at being singled out over flu fear

  • Published: 10/07/2009 at 12:00 AM
  • Newspaper section: News

Private tutorial schools across the country have been ordered closed for more than a fortnight to help curb the spread of type-A (H1N1) flu.


Students at a Siam Square tutorial school read an announcement suspending classes fromMondayto July 28 in an attempt to curb the spread of type-A (H1N1) flu virus. KOSOL NAKACHOL

The order does not apply to normal schools.

The closure, which takes effect from Monday to July 28, was greeted with anger from school operators.

. But the move has the full backing of Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva. The Private Education Commission under the Education Ministry has been assigned to implement the order.

The commission said there were 1,232 private tutorial schools registered with the ministry.

The order is based on a Public Health Ministry proposal which identified tutorial schools and computer game shops as major A (H1N1) transmission points for children - one of the most vulnerable groups to infection.

However, neither the Education Ministry nor the Public Health Ministry has the authority to shut down the game shops. All the ministries can do is ask them to close their doors for a while.

The Culture Ministry has been assigned by the cabinet to ask the game shops to make sure their computer equipment is hygienic, improve their ventilation and provide their customers with antiseptic hand gel. The government wants internet cafes to do the same.

"The government wants them to clean up to prevent flu infections," the prime minister said.

Mr Abhisit also asked for the cooperation of students and parents, saying pupils with flu symptoms should stay at home and not worry about tests at schools.

"The Education Ministry will allow them to take their exams later," he said.

All school executives have been given the authority to decide whether to shut their schools if they suspect any of their students have come down with the flu.

Education Minister Jurin Laksanavisit said the Public Health Ministry had come up with a new system to take care of students suspected of contracting the virus. The system would be put in place on Monday, when medical teams would be set up specifically to deal with students thought to have caught the flu.

Schools will be required to isolate students with flu-like symptoms and entrust them to the medical teams.

Schools have also been told to hold classes for students who miss school while ill so they can catch up.


Owners of tutorial schools reacted angrily to the closure order.

Anusorn Sivakul, head of the Tutorial Schools Association, said the closure was a stunt to make it look as if the government was stepping up efforts to stop A (H1N1) flu.

He said he was not convinced it would address the root cause of the problem. The decision to close tutorial schools was based on ill-founded information.

"Tutorial school operators wonder what information the Public Health Ministry is using to claim that tutorial schools are breeding grounds for the virus," Mr Anusorn said.

If tutorial schools were a breeding ground for the virus, the number of infections would be even higher given that they are attended by hundreds of thousands of students, he said.

Puea Thai Party spokesman Prompong Nopparit said Public Health Minister Witthaya Kaewparadai lacked experience and had failed to deal with the flu outbreak. He called on the prime minister to dismiss Mr Witthaya.

Mr Prompong urged the government to fight the spread of the virus as a national priority and use an integrated approach in doing so. He also said the goverment should cover medical costs.

About the author

Writer: ANUCHA CHAROENPO and SIRIKUL BUNNAG

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • jiri

    Discussion 10 : 10/07/2009 at 08:34 PM10

    here here, close ALL suspected schools. I have no idea what type of quality policy analysts and politicians in Thailand possess.

  • passerbee

    Discussion 9 : 10/07/2009 at 05:11 PM9

    @paul

    i was about to write the same.

    @bangkokray

    i don't know for how you've already been followed thai news but this has surely very little to do with the current administration. the solution seems so very typical thai again (nomatter who has the power). and i'm sad to say this.

  • Benz

    Discussion 8 : 10/07/2009 at 04:44 PM8

    I think it would probably be effective if all the schools are closed due to this global pandemic. However, I'm not feeling well enough with closing all the cram schools because the upcoming examinations are approaching so they students need time to prepare for their exams. 15 days are too much :(

  • Bill W

    Discussion 7 : 10/07/2009 at 12:31 PM7

    Students shouldn't need tutoring schools anyway. They should be tested on their past ability to learn, retain information and THINK. These schools many times just encourage the kind of draconian thinking and rote memorization that is endemic in the Thai education system now.

    I do feel sorry for them in that they are being singled out for a rather minor situation. You're right John...Your more likely to die from crossing the street here than the H1N1 virus!

  • BangkokRay

    Discussion 6 : 10/07/2009 at 11:46 AM6

    This is an absolute farce. It's like putting a band aid on a gushing wound. If they were serious and a real problem actually existed, they should close ALL schools and other facilities that had close congregations of people. This administration is nothing but a joke.

  • Mrs D

    Discussion 5 : 10/07/2009 at 11:02 AM5

    schools are close so students will go around shopping, going around the town...n survey around without masks and what we have to do..?? SOME INTERNET SHOP didn't close...how about train stations and bus stations?? if u wear the mask all will afraid u..do something for all,,,wish u luck

  • observer

    Discussion 4 : 10/07/2009 at 10:50 AM4

    What a joke. I suppose if they can do this for a weak swine flu, they will start doing this every flu season?

    I think the government is no longer taking the public interest into account - they seem to be doing the bidding of a few.

  • Mac

    Discussion 3 : 10/07/2009 at 08:16 AM3

    Will this move have any significant impact on the spread of the flu? No. Just another empty gesture of politicians who want to be seen doing something on a media generated scare story, even if it is really really stupid.

    BTW, this swine flu is much milder than normal flu, death rates are significantly lower, and the risk to the public health marginal. The media frenzy surrounding the flu originated when it was feared this could be a lethal virus that could kill millions. Turns out it this flu virus is less lethal than normal flu viruses and the original fears are unfounded. Makes the continued media scare mongering and government over- reaction look all the more pathetic.

  • John in BKK

    Discussion 2 : 10/07/2009 at 07:59 AM2

    You are significantly more likely to die in Bangkok from a traffic accident or food poisoning. Political will should be directed to solve the problems that affects the most lives, not what the media finds interesting for the week.

  • Paul

    Discussion 1 : 10/07/2009 at 07:06 AM1

    The decision to close only tutorial schools really puzzles me. One would expect tutorial schools to be less crowded than normal public schools. After all, the parents have to pay extra for these tutorial services, and they would only will be willing to do so if their kids get the attention they don't get in normal schools

    I still remember when WHO raised the alert level of HIN1 to 6 (pendemic), the Thai government thought that it was totally unnecessary and planned to file a protest (as that would scarce off tourists). Their atitude definitely has changed swifty within a very short ime.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top