Bangkok Post : Hmong returnees look life in eye in barren land

Send suggestions

News » Local News

Hmong returnees look life in eye in barren land

FUTURE UNCERTAIN SINCE THAI GOVT SENT THEM BACK TO LAOS

  • Published: 28/02/2010 at 12:00 AM
  • Newspaper section: News

BORIKHAMXAY, LAOS : Hmong people repatriated from Thailand to start a new life at a resettlement village in Laos are unsure whether their lives hold out the prospect of much improvement.

LITTLE HOPE: Some of the repatriated children. PHOTO: SURAPOL PROMSAKA NA SAKOLNAKORN

Ban Thonekhan village, 150km east of the capital Vientiane, is in the country's mountainous centre. It is home to 2,768 Hmong repatriated from Ban Huay Nam Khao camp in Phetchabun on Dec 28 last year, and 155 Hmong from Nong Khai who had persons of concern status.

They were among 4,350 Hmong sent from the Thai camp over international objections.

More than 500 Lao people live in the village already, but the Lao government is hurriedly redeveloping the area to settle the new arrivals. It has built 400 of the 600 houses that will be needed, with the rest due to be completed next month.

The Thai government _ which regarded them as illegal economic migrants _ insisted they left voluntarily. However, it kept the media at a distance as soldiers, armed with riot shields and batons, shepherded the asylum-seekers into buses and trucks for the journey back across the border last year.

Among the Hmong are 155 who were held at a detention centre in Nong Khai, and have ''persons of concern'' status. Some had been promised resettlement in third countries including the United States, which says it will accept 70 from this group.

The Lao government invited the Thai delegation, including journalists, to visit the resettlement village last week. It wants to allay reports that the Hmong had left Thailand under duress or were mistreated. Nipat Thonglek, head of the Royal Armed Forces' Department of Bor der Affairs, led the delegation.

It was the first official Thai visit to the village since the repatriated Hmong left the camps. The Hmong people who met them at the village sang a native song of welcome. The lyrics confessed their guilt at having left the motherland, and asserting their happiness at having returned. However, the optimistic message of the song was at odds with how many of the Hmong really feel.

Va Kia, 50, originally from Xaisomboon, was detained at Nong Khai immigration centre until Feb 28 last year.

The United Nations gave her a card attesting to her ''person of concern'' status, which she believes gave her entitlement to resettle in the US.

However, no one has followed up on the promise, so she faces the prospect of spending life at the village instead.

''They said that after 30 days back in Laos, they would take us on to the third countries. But it's been nearly two months now, and nobody has come.''

The isolated village is on former forestry land. The Lao government won't say how much it has spent on resettling the Hmong so far, but says a total of US$8 million (264.3 million baht) will be needed to build schools and put up basic infrastructure. It is appealing for foreign support.

A Hmong man, 32, also given person of concern status, said he, too, faces an uncertain future. He left a jungle home near the Vietnamese border in Borikhamxay province several years ago with five other family members.

''Because we do not have Lao citizenship, somebody said we should go to Thailand. I paid him the equivalent of nearly 6,000 baht.

''We were afraid to stay in the jungle, so we crossed the border. We heard during our stay in Bangkok that the UN would protect us, so we contacted them. Our family is being resettled in the Netherlands, but at the moment we do not know what lies ahead.'' Hmong woman Pai Seya, 40, said she was not happy. ''While in Thailand I could speak my feelings, but here I cannot,'' said Pai, from the Ban Huay Nam Khao camp.

Earlier in Vientiane, Jo Luo, 20, refused to comment on claims that she had been raped by Lao soldiers. ''I don't want to further talk about this, especially before TV cameras and a huge crowd.''

She was among four people from Nong Khai detention centre to which the US has paid special concern. The other three were siblings, aged between seven and nine years. The family of a Lao reporter has now adopted two girls, and a boy has been returned to his Hmong father.

Jo Luo said she left home alone hoping for a better life in Thailand, but ended up cleaning dishes at a Bangkok restaurant. She was rounded up, and eventually sent to Nong Khai.

Lt Gen Nipat said Thailand had repatriated 7,780 Hmong in 22 trips since November 2006.

Give us your ideas!

What do you want to see at the website? We need your input! We appreciate your suggestions.

Take survey

About the author

columnist
Writer: Achara Ashayagachat
Position: Reporter

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • Tomak

    Discussion 7 : 03/03/2010 at 02:50 AM7

    Why should the International community fork $6 million to Laos when the government, time after time, refused and rejected international concerns in regards to these returnees? I agree that Hmong are diligent people and certainly don't need someone else to feed them. Show them the tools and they will do a heck of a better job than you and the govn't.

  • Laajkham

    Discussion 6 : 01/03/2010 at 09:36 PM6

    Actually, Hmong are very diligent people. They usually don't depend on any party to feed them. As soon as they migrated from China to Laos, they lived peacefully in the highland of Laos being self-sufficient until the French colonized Laos and forced them to pay high taxes and taught them to grow opium and later be materialized by the CIA to force them to be hungry. The pain is that they were/are in remote areas where they did not have good access to education, and their intelligence fell a little behind, and greedy people, like the French and the CIA, had the advantage to use them like tools and pawns. No matter what, human beings have sense and feelings. When their feelings heat up, be ware!

  • Nejkuvnco

    Discussion 5 : 01/03/2010 at 01:09 PM5

    Thank you for this article. Thank you to the Lao government for building these shelters for the returnees. Hopefully, the returnees will be able to integrate into normal Lao society.

  • bprapenee

    Discussion 4 : 28/02/2010 at 11:48 AM4

    the thai people themselves were "illegal economic migrants". that is how they arrived in what is (now) called thailand.but foreigner's can not own property there. how ironic 555

  • kondtangchaat

    Discussion 3 : 28/02/2010 at 11:40 AM3

    the hmong were in china before the chinese.unlike the french occupation of vietnam, the hmong never forced themselves upon others.look at the "Rebecca Sommers" video on youtube.com decide for yourself.

  • Laajkham

    Discussion 2 : 28/02/2010 at 09:14 AM2

    It is sad that the Hmong had to be treated this way, but no matter what, they are back in their homeland. One can only hopes that the Lao government will really keep its words--let the returnees to integrate into mainstream Lao society.

    It is disappointed that they no longer has any freedom of speech. Hope they are not penalized for what they said in this article.

  • souvenirdeparis

    Discussion 1 : 28/02/2010 at 04:32 AM1

    I'm glad Thailand, one of my son's homelands, doesn't have to support 4000+
    people with no qualifications.
    I see 400 houses have already been built for them , I hope they'll start being productive citizens for Laos to pay back their dues.
    Here in France immigrants, legal & illegal , are supposed to pay my retirement later, but for the time being they mostly live on welfare ... better luck to the govt of Laos.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar


  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top