Political realignments - backing and 'baramee'

GMT +07:00

Send suggestions

Opinion » Opinion

Political realignments - backing and 'baramee'

  • Published: 9/10/2009 at 12:00 AM
  • Newspaper section: News

In view of the New Politics Party's formal selection of Sondhi Limthongkul as its leader, the political party scene has now undergone its most transformative realignment since the military coup three years ago.

Gen Chavalit Yongchaiyudh, right, and Puea Thai Party leader Yongyuth Wichadit raise hands after the general applied for party membership on Oct 2, 2009.

Manoeuvres and movements among the other leading parties, featuring the Democrat Party (DP), Bhumjaithai Party (BJT) and Puea Thai Party (PT), indicate that the ongoing shifts in party politics is attributable not just to potential polls but also to corresponding political backing behind the scenes. Such backing and the role of what is known as baramee have never been so intrusive and protrusive in Thai politics.

For the NPP, Mr Sondhi has bit the bullet by going back on his pledge soon after he founded and co-led the four-year-old People's Alliance for Democracy (PAD). His previously professed role as a selfless "watchdog" of the land has now been converted to a political party leader. By acknowledging that it is unlikely to win more than a handful of seats in the eventual polls, the NPP is not touting itself as a party of the masses. Its constituents remain a narrow column whose commitment and resolve are deep.

As a result, the NPP has stated its intention to hold the PAD in reserve as a street mob auxiliary. In effect, the PAD is now set to function alongside the NPP in a mutually reinforcing movement going in the same direction. The NPP would not have sufficient weight by going through electoral and parliamentary channels. Without the NPP, the PAD cannot make things happen the way it wants. It can bring down governments but it is not allowed to govern. A veto power in the streets is not enough. It now wants to directly dictate and determine outcomes.

Mr Sondhi's initial ambivalence towards a role in the cut-and-thrust electoral arena has given way to a new political direction. Having narrowly survived a gangland-style assassination attempt, and now being hounded by criminal convictions and ongoing lawsuits, Mr Sondhi has had to raise the stakes. His convictions have transpired just as politicians of many stripes, who jumped ship and joined the DP-led government of Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva in time, have been acquitted on an array of charges.

The backing and protection Mr Sondhi had during the PAD's wrath and rampage last year is apparently not what it used to be.

Members of the People’s Alliance for Democracy raise their hands after electing Sondhi Limthongkul (centre) as leader of the New Politics Party, at Muang Thong Thani on Tuesday.

After the Abhisit government took power, the PAD has been increasingly neglected and bypassed. The ruling Democrats naturally had other plans to pursue and challenges to address. The army has lined up behind the BJT to prop up the DP-led coalition. The PAD can still make plenty of noise but not enough difference.

The NPP's logo and slogan are thus revealing. Its logo comprises four yellow hands set against a green background. The yellow hands appear somehow intended to work alongside the green, as the PAD has never been about environmental protection.

More revealing is its catchy slogan. The genesis of the PAD has been about anti-corruption on the one hand and the crown on the other, subsequently incorporating nationalism and xenophobia. To the PAD, fugitive PM Thaksin Shinawatra fell foul of both and was attacked for corruption and disloyalty to the monarchy.

But the NPP's slogan stipulates integrity, sacrifice, perseverance, and an ability to get things done. Integrity is aimed for Thaksin's ilk, whereas effective performance can be seen as a sarcasm for the DP. Sacrifice and perseverance are the staples of PAD foot soldiers in their repeated protests through rain storms and scorching sun, especially for much of last year.

The absence of a royalist rallying cry in its slogan is presumably not a manifestation of disrespect but a de-emphasis in a new environment. Having served its backers and achieved the ouster of the Thaksin-backed governments last year, the PAD's efficacy had reached its limits. The lack of backing it had last year explains the PAD's reduced baramee - the perceived and real sources of authority and power underpinned by simple courtesy and overt clout, translatable into preferences and outcomes.

The NPP is thus the PAD's logical way ahead.

Backing and baramee are still with Mr Abhisit and the DP. His tussle with the BJT over the police chief appointment suggests that the baramee is around rather than in him. The resignation of Niphon Phromphan as the PM's secretary-general, who is a quiet but quite effective operative with much baramee, is a blow to the DP going forward. The ruling party will increasingly be cannibalised by the NPP, which relies on the same urban-based, middle class-driven constituencies in Bangkok and the major provincial centres. The DP is worst off after the recent realignments.

Both the BJT and PT are in a holding pattern but in different directions. With firm backing from the army, the BJT has upside gains from defections of other troubled parties and politicians, and from the benefits of government largess. The distribution of public funds will gain votes and bolster its war chest for the next election. By jousting with the PM over the new police chief selection, the BJT has shown that it has ample baramee and backing to leverage itself as electoral kingmaker at a minimum.

Because it lacks baramee and backing, the PT has brought in Gen Chavalit Yongchaiyudh as party adviser. Gen Chavalit was prime minister during the economic maelstrom in 1996-97 and was seen as an inept, serial fumbler. His only credit perhaps was a willingness to resign from the army to enter the political arena in the late 1980s, thereby playing by the rules. Yet the PT does not have much left to turn to. Its main talent is banned after the dissolutions of its two predecessors. The PT's appointment of Gen Chavalit is intended to increase its baramee on the face of the party and in behind-the-scenes manoeuvres.

The recent political realignments and political party shuffles are also all about positioning and posturing ahead of the polls and political change that is to come. They represent a crucial juncture that will move Thai politics and transformation to the next stage. Backing and baramee still hover over the landscape. The stakes and attendant risks are growing for the protagonists in the political arena and for the backers beyond.

  • The writer is Director of the Institute of Security and International Studies, Faculty of Political Science, Chulalongkorn University.

About the author

columnist
Writer: Thitinan Pongsudhirak
Position: Director of the Institute of Security and Internat

Share your thoughts

For more candid, lengthy, conversational and open discussion between one another, use our Forum

Report objectionable comments click here. Include: discussion #, commenter name, comment date / time as it looks on the page. Example: discussion 15: 09/01/2009 at 10:00 AM.

  • Somboon

    Discussion 7 : 09/10/2009 at 11:21 PM7

    Steve,

    Well-stated. The Post should do an article on this and do research/investigative before printing it out though.

    Win-Win,

    Academic thinks they have "baramee" also. Not all, but most of them do. They think because they have a PhD/MD: and therefore, they are higher than others. I have dealt with PhDs for the last 29 years and a lot of them are full of it. Media in Thailand are so biased and do not have substantiation most of the time, even the Post itself.

    The Generals have a whole lot of "baramee" also.

  • Independent Thai

    Discussion 6 : 09/10/2009 at 02:08 PM6

    It is the good opinion of Thai politic. I still don't know exactly what do you mean by"baramee"
    Can you educate me to my ignorance of Thai politic?

    We need many things to improve the democratic system in Thailand such as education of people,news and knowledge of the action of government and politicians,trustworthly of Thai medias,ethic and moral Thai journalist.If all of these are up to standard and unity of Thai people,we can change political situation in Thailand.
    The power of change is in the hearted-mind of Thai people who want to change.We can get rid of crooked and corrupted politicians and government,"baramee "groups by people's power.
    We had done many,many time in the history of Thailand.Unfortunately the country went back to be the same situation,because Thai people do not want to change their habitual behavior.
    We have had fallen in love with greedy,selfishness,power and status,fame,arrogance.The 'baramee" groups are clever and know how to control Thai people for their own benifits.This is the sad story in Thailand. WHAT CAN WE DO?

  • Win - Win

    Discussion 5 : 09/10/2009 at 12:43 PM5

    Dear Professor,
    Can academic and media help promote the WIN-WIN problem solving method and good governance to the public& politic.
    The new constitution should be designed by professionals or good policy makers not lawyer nor politicians in order to have a practical main law for good sake of Thailand and avoid previous mistakes.Lawyers to review and write in nice legal pattern not a trap like2550 version. The yellow - red card system to be cancelled.The cabinet to be educated and professional.PM to be directly elected

  • Steve

    Discussion 4 : 09/10/2009 at 12:26 PM4

    Picking up on Somboon's comment (#3), I suspect that many non-Thai reading this article will be wondering what is really meant by the term "baramee" mentioned so often in it. As it's something I (as a non-Thai) looked into previously, I'll pass on what I found in the hope that it goes some way to help explain what is a very Thai concept - even if it's not possible to give an exact translation.

    In a purely Buddhist context, someone who has great baramee is 'a very influential and respectable figure', 'a highly charismatic individual' probably possessing the "Ten Perfections" (liberality, morality, renunciation of the world, wisdom, perseverance, forbearance, truth, determination, loving kindness and equanimity). So, a very learned/revered Abbot will have much baramee - and his blessing (possibly advice) will be seen to have great significance and value. Likewise, monks blessing a wedding or a new house/business have baramee - though less than the senior and more revered Abbot.

    By extension to the more worldly context of Thai politics and business - as Somboon says - the term seems to be regarded more as describing the power/influence of a high-status (therefore powerful) individual or group of individuals (institution) in a position to confer the benefit of their approval and, of course, also withhold their approval. In common English parlance, we'd probably call it "pull" or "clout" - but, because of the Buddhist connotations, it probably carries more weight for Thai than those terms suggest.

    I hope that's helpful - and also hope that a Thai reader will correct or add to my interpretation if they think it's necessary.

  • Somboon

    Discussion 3 : 09/10/2009 at 10:40 AM3

    No, "baramee" is not jus a political backing behind the scenes.

    "Baramee" includes the class, status, wealth, power and so forth. When you talk "baramee," you have to include "phuyai" since they have a lot of "baramee."

    "Baramee" is one of the main problems in Thai culture hindering democracy.

  • Neutral

    Discussion 2 : 09/10/2009 at 09:17 AM2

    MT, I can understand your emotion regarding politics. But really, political intrigues are part and parcel of a democratic process. What is more critical is that politics should be about ballot box. Multi parties can do all the shouting & shadow play and employed as much allies with baramee as they want but compete at election time. It is when undemocratic means were employed to terminate a democratically elected party, it does sickened everybody.

  • mt

    Discussion 1 : 09/10/2009 at 07:16 AM1

    I am speechless and sickened by politics.

Reply

    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
    • avatar
  • As a courtesy to our readers, please use proper punctuation and correct spelling.

back to top