Fresh look needed on refugees | Bangkok Post: opinion

Opinion > Opinion

Fresh look needed on refugees

The announcement on Friday from Foreign Minister Surapong Tovichakchaikul that Rohingya who have washed up on Thai shores will be sheltered for another six months should be commended. Meanwhile, negotiations with Myanmar and other countries in the region to find a permanent settlement solution will be ongoing. Realistically, however, it is unlikely that this thorny issue will be resolved in six months. Thailand must be prepared to extend the arrangement for the approximately 1,400 Rohingya estimated to be in the country.

Predominantly Muslim members of Asean, Malaysia and Indonesia in particular, should lead the way toward a solution, and it should be a priority at the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation's summit in Cairo next week.

The best solution would, of course, be for the Myanmar government to take responsibility for the Rohingya by granting them citizenship and assuring them protection against mobs who see them as a threat. Currently the government is denying the Rohingya nationality because it says they originally crossed the border illegally from Bangladesh, even though many have now been in the country for generations. The stance has brought harsh rebukes from humanitarian groups as well as from governments that are anxious to endorse Myanmar's reform process. But while the violence directed at Rohingya in Rakhine state, reportedly in many instances condoned by the authorities, should be thoroughly condemned, it must also be admitted that Myanmar is not alone in taking such a position. For example, there is little chance that Thailand will grant citizenship to the tens of thousands of Myanmar nationals who have crossed the border in recent decades for political and economic reasons.

This article is older than 60 days, which we reserve for our premium members only.You can subscribe to our premium member subscription, here.

Your comments

  • Discussion 3 : 27 Jan 2013 at 19.513

    How many interviews have you read with any of the recent Rohingya arrivals? Me either. How about asking them where they were making for instead of declaring "You shall be happy in Bangladesh!", or wherever. And why on earth would they get on a boat going in the other direction if they wanted to go to Bangladesh? These people were probably trying for Malaysia and a life. Let the UNHCR determine their status and then act in their best interest.

  • pjt

    ThailandPost : 911

    Send message

    Discussion 2 : 27 Jan 2013 at 09.402

    Is not the main problem the creation of statelessness? The ability of nations to disavow their subjects right to citizenship. It seems to me that if you give an inalienable right to each person that they acquire rights to citizenship in their country of birth, then you would go some way to solve this problem (albeit over a period of time). You could still claim citizenship rights through your parents to cover the cases where children are born overseas to migrant/expat workers - but at least with this rule you would have one indisputable right to be recognised by a state

  • Discussion 1 : 27 Jan 2013 at 05.151

    Let's stand in the shoes of the Rohingyas themselves. They do not want to be in Myanmar. They do not want to be exploited in strange lands like Thailand or other countries further south.

    Rohingyas are ethno-linguistically related to the Indo-Aryan peoples of Bangladesh. They share the same religion too. They will be very happy in Bangladesh.

    The international community and especially the OIC should help the Rohingyas move to Bangladesh. I am sure the super wealthy oil nations in the OIC can come up with the funds to help Bangladesh foot the bills.

    Win-Win situation for everyone. And no need to blame Thailand for anything.

Reply

Sign in once and access every part of the website at your convenience!

Please log in to our Bangkokpost.com community to post your comment.
You can sign in to the community by clicking here.

If you are not part of the community yet, please sign up here. By being part of this community you will get all these privileges.