Mars sues woman over her brand of chocolates
published : 6 Apr 2017 at 10:00
newspaper section: Business
writer: Associated Press
MILWAUKEE: Candy maker Mars Inc is suing a Wisconsin woman over chocolates she is selling under a name that the company argues is "confusingly similar'' to its cocoa extract supplements called CocoaVia.
The McLean, Virginia-based company said in a federal lawsuit filed on March 24 that the chocolates sold in Madison by Syovata Edari "will likely confuse and deceive consumers because they're branded as CocoVaa.''
This photo taken in February shows chocolatier Syovata Edari with one of her products. AP
The company contends the similarity in the brand names hurts Mars' reputation and Edari should be barred from using CocoVaa on her products.
The company is also seeking damages to be determined at trial and all of Edari's profits.
"The lawsuit is trademark bullying,'' Edari said on Tuesday and noted that her chocolates "are distinctly different than the product in question that Mars sells.''
Mars markets the cocoa extracts in CocoaVia as promoting "healthy blood flow from head to toe,'' according to the lawsuit.
Edari said she picked her brand name because "Vaa'' was her father's nickname for her as a child. "It's clear that what I'm making are mousses, caramels and ganaches, not health supplements.''
"I actually invited them so they could see, 'Hey, you don't have to worry about me. I'm doing something completely different','' she told the Associated Press.
Her trademark was registered on March 14.
But the company maintains the name similarity will mislead the public and create the impression that Mars manufactures or approves of the chocolates Edari is selling.
"We work hard to create and build our brands, and so we protect our trademark rights,'' Denise Young, a company spokeswoman, said in a statement.
"Mars could not comment further because the lawsuit is pending,'' Young added.
Edari, who began making chocolates to promote her law practice, said she would be representing herself in the case, which is being handled in Virginia's Eastern District Court.
"I'm comfortable in federal court,'' Edari said, noting her experience as a federal public defender. "I welcome that opportunity to put this in front of a jury.''