'Belt and Road' is buckling under scrutiny
published : 1 Oct 2018 at 03:55
newspaper section: News
On a recent official visit to China, Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad criticised his host country's use of major infrastructure projects -- and difficult-to-repay loans -- to assert its influence over smaller countries. While Dr Mahathir's warnings in Beijing against "a new version of colonialism" stood out for their boldness, they reflect a broader pushback against China's mercantilist trade, investment, and lending practices.
Since 2013, under the umbrella of its "Belt and Road Initiative", China has been funding and implementing large infrastructure projects in countries around the world, to help align their interests with its own, gain a political foothold in strategic locations, and export its industrial surpluses.
By keeping bidding on BRI projects closed and opaque, China often massively inflates their value, leaving countries struggling to repay their debts.
Once countries become ensnared in China's debt traps, they can end up being forced into even worse deals to compensate for the lack of repayment.
Most notably, last December, Sri Lanka was compelled to transfer the Chinese-built strategic port of Hambantota to China on a 99-year, colonial-style lease, because it could no longer afford its debt payments.
Sri Lanka's experience was a wake-up call for other countries with outsize debts to China. Fearing that they, too, could lose strategic assets, they are now attempting to scrap, scale back, or renegotiate their deals. Dr Mahathir, who previously cleared the way for Chinese investment in Malaysia, ended his trip to Beijing by cancelling Chinese projects worth almost US$23 billion.
Countries as diverse as Bangladesh, Hungary, and Tanzania have also canceled or scaled back BRI projects.
Myanmar, hoping to secure needed infrastructure without becoming caught up in a Chinese debt trap, has used the threat of cancellation to negotiate a reduction in the cost of its planned Kyaukpyu port from $7.3 billion to $1.3 billion.
Even China's closest partners are now wary of the BRI. In Pakistan, which has long worked with China to contain India and is the largest recipient of BRI financing, the new military-backed government has sought to review or renegotiate projects in response to a worsening debt crisis.
In Cambodia, another leading recipient of Chinese loans, fears of effectively becoming a Chinese colony are on the rise.
The backlash against China can be seen elsewhere, too. The recent annual Pacific Islands Forum meeting was one of the most contentious in its history.
Chinese policies in the region, together with the Chinese delegation leader's behaviour at the event itself, drove the president of Nauru -- the world's smallest republic with just 11,000 inhabitants -- to condemn China's "arrogant" presence in the South Pacific.
China cannot, he declared, "dictate things to us".
When it comes to trade, US President Donald Trump's escalating trade war with China is grabbing headlines, but Mr Trump is far from alone in criticising China. With policies ranging from export subsidies and non-tariff barriers to intellectual-property piracy and tilting the domestic market in favour of Chinese companies, China represents, in the words of Harvard's Graham Allison, the "most protectionist, mercantilist, and predatory major economy in the world".
As the largest merchandise exporter in the world, China is many countries' biggest trading partner. Beijing has leveraged this role by employing trade to punish those that refuse to toe its line, including by imposing import bans on specific products, halting strategic exports (such as rare-earth minerals), cutting off tourism from China, and encouraging domestic consumer boycotts or protests against foreign businesses.
The fact is that China has grown strong and rich by flouting international trade rules. But now its chickens are coming home to roost, with a growing number of countries imposing anti-dumping or punitive duties on Chinese goods. And as countries worry about China bending them to its will by luring them into debt traps, it is no longer smooth sailing for the BRI.
Beyond Mr Trump's tariffs, the European Union has filed a complaint with the World Trade Organisation about China's practices of forcing technology transfer as a condition of market access. China's export subsidies and other trade-distorting practices are set to encounter greater international resistance.
Under WTO rules, countries may impose tariffs on subsidised goods from overseas that harm domestic industries.
Now, Chinese President Xi Jinping finds himself not only defending the BRI, his signature foreign-policy initiative, but also confronting domestic criticism, however muted, for flaunting China's global ambitions and thereby inviting a US-led international backlash.
Mr Xi has discarded one of former Chinese strongman Deng Xiaoping's most famous dicta: "Hide your strength, bide your time".
Instead, Mr Xi has chosen to pursue an unabashedly aggressive strategy that has many asking whether China is emerging as a new kind of imperialist power.
International trade has afforded China enormous benefits, enabling the country to become the world's second-largest economy, while lifting hundreds of millions of people out of poverty. The country cannot afford to lose those benefits to an international backlash against its unfair trade and investment practices.
China's reliance on large trade surpluses and foreign-exchange reserves to fund the expansion of its global footprint makes it all the more vulnerable to the current pushback.
In fact, even if China shifts its strategy and adheres to international rules, its trade surplus and foreign-currency reserves will be affected.
In short, whichever path it chooses, China's free ride could be coming to an end. - PROJECT SYNDICATE
Brahma Chellaney, Professor of Strategic Studies at the New Delhi-based Centre for Policy Research and Fellow at the Robert Bosch Academy in Berlin, is the author of nine books, including 'Asian Juggernaut, Water: Asia's New Battleground', and 'Water, Peace, and War: Confronting the Global Water Crisis'.
Brahma Chellaney, Professor of Strategic Studies at the New Delhi-based Center for Policy Research and Fellow at the Robert Bosch Academy in Berlin, is the author of nine books, including ‘Asian Juggernaut’, ‘Water: Asia’s New Battleground’ and ‘Water, Peace and War: Confronting the Global Water Crisis’.
- debt traps
- export subsidies