Phuketwan journalists acquitted in navy defamation trial

Phuketwan journalists acquitted in navy defamation trial

Australian journalist Alan Morison (right) and Thai journalist Chutima Sidasathian smile as they arrive at court in Phuket Sept 1. The court on the cleared the two journalists on Tuesday of defaming the Thai navy and other related charges. (Reuters photo)
Australian journalist Alan Morison (right) and Thai journalist Chutima Sidasathian smile as they arrive at court in Phuket Sept 1. The court on the cleared the two journalists on Tuesday of defaming the Thai navy and other related charges. (Reuters photo)

Two journalists, including an Australian editor, were found not guilty of criminal defamation by Phuket Provincial Court on Tuesday, their lawyer said, over a report implicating the Thai navy in human trafficking.

They were also acquitted of another charge of breaching the Computer Crimes Act in a high-profile trial that had sparked widespread condemnation from human rights groups and the United Nations.

Amnesty International instantly sent out a press release, calling the decision a "small step in the right direction".

"The two should never have had to stand trial in the first place, Amnesty International said.

"This is just the latest in a long line of attacks on freedom of expression and media outlets since the military seized power in 2014," claimed Josef Benedict, AI's Southeast Asia Campaigns Director.

Alan Morison and his Thai colleague Chutima Sidasathian, of the Phuketwan news website, had faced up to seven years in jail over a July 2013 article quoting an investigation by the Reuters news agency which said some Thai navy members were involved in trafficking Rohingya Muslims fleeing Myanmar.

"The court has acquitted (the pair)," their lawyer Siriwan Vongkietpaisan told AFP shortly after the verdict was delivered at Phuket Provincial Court.

"Phuketwan had only presented their (Reuters') information that had already been published on their website," she added.

The Phuket verdict comes after the region's grim people-smuggling trade was dramatically laid bare this year when migrants were abandoned at sea and in jungle death camps by traffickers following a Thai crackdown, a crisis that eventually forced Southeast Asian governments to respond.

The two journalists had been facing up to two years in jail for criminal defamation and five years for breaching the Computer Crimes Act after the navy sued Phuketwan for defamation in response to their article.

Reuters has not been charged over its reporting — part of a series honoured with a Pulitzer Prize last year — and rights groups have accused the navy of trying to muzzle the smaller Phuket-based English-language media outlet.

David Crundwell, a chief spokesman for Reuters, said the agency was "pleased" to hear the verdict.

"Reuters wholeheartedly supports the principles of a free press, and the imperative of journalists across the world to publish independent and reliable news," he said.

Speaking to AFP ahead of the verdict Chutima said "the authorities can cover up problems but you can't cover up everything".

Southern Thailand has long been known as a nexus for lucrative and largely unchecked smuggling networks through which persecuted Rohingya Muslims in Buddhist-majority Myanmar, and Bangladeshi economic migrants, among others, would pass on their way to Malaysia.

Officials have long been accused by human rights groups of turning both a blind eye to, and complicity in, the trade.

A crackdown in May led to the unravelling of vast people-smuggling networks.

In July Thai prosecutors announced that 72 people have been indicted, including local officials and a senior army general.

However no other military figures have been arrested, something that has raised eyebrows among rights groups and observers who say it is unlikely such an influential officer would have acted alone.

Last month — for the second year in a row — Thailand was placed by the United States on the bottom tier of its ranking of countries failing to tackle human trafficking alongside nations like Iran, Libya, North Korea and Syria.

The current crackdown came after the reporting period of the State Department's latest "Trafficking in Persons" report ended and Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-Cha has expressed hopes his country will be upgraded next year.



Do you like the content of this article?
COMMENT (11)

All but one Wuhan returnee cleared of Covid-19

CHON BURI: One of the 138 quarantined Thai returnees from Wuhan showed a small presence of the novel coronavirus (Covid-19), but the others were healthy and ready to be discharged from quarantine, a senior health official said on Tuesday.

12:59

Korat shooting victims to receive more money Wednesday

NAKHON RATCHASIMA: Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha will preside at the hand-over of additional remedial payments on Wednesday to victims of the Feb 8-9 shooting rampage, provincial governor Wichian Chantaranothai said on Tuesday.

12:09

Cabbie arrested for detaining, raping woman

A taxi driver wanted for the alleged detention and forcible rape of a woman in Bangk’s Bung Kum district has been arrested nearly three years later.

11:43