Subsidence spurs checks on India's hydro push
text size

Subsidence spurs checks on India's hydro push

Residents take part in a sit-in protest to halt the demolition of two hotels deemed unsafe by authorities in Joshimath, Uttarakhand, India. REUTERS
Residents take part in a sit-in protest to halt the demolition of two hotels deemed unsafe by authorities in Joshimath, Uttarakhand, India. REUTERS

Posters urging "NTPC Go Back" have appeared in Joshimath, a subsiding Indian Himalayan town where roads are cracking and houses crumbling -- a crisis locals blame largely on a hydropower project led by India's biggest electricity producer NTPC.

Residents in the tourist hub of Joshimath are demanding a halt to the project, in the latest of a wave of protests across regions where hydroelectric facilities are being built, as India boosts clean energy to cut its planet-heating carbon emissions.

As Joshimath charity worker Kalawati Sah did her rounds assessing homes in areas marked as "unsafe" last week, she said the cracks were spreading to more structures.

Locals attribute the sinking of their town in northern Uttarakhand state and the damage to infrastructure to tunnel-boring for the hydropower project and lack of a drainage system.

Similar concerns have been raised over the past decade in neighbouring Himachal Pradesh, one of four key states identified by India for expanding hydropower generation.

Government estimates show that India has hydro potential of 145,320 megawatts -- enough to power about 140 million households or all homes in the United States -- but installed capacity had reached only about 47,000MW by the end of last year.

Officials regard hydropower as essential for India to meet its 2030 renewable energy target of 500 gigawatts.

But the projects are cutting through mountains and forests, forcing people from their homes and triggering calls to save sensitive ecological areas like the Himalayas -- even though adopting clean energy could help curb climate change and limit the negative effects of warming temperatures on the mountains.

The crisis in Joshimath has strengthened scrutiny of India's push for more hydropower to help balance rising energy demand while cutting planet-heating emissions to net zero by 2070.

India's power minister told journalists last week that construction of the NTPC project had not led to land subsidence or cracks in Joshimath.

But researcher Manshi Asher of the Himdhara Environment Research and Action Collective said her group had been documenting the damage caused by hydropower projects in the Himalayas for over a decade and campaigning against them.

"The sheer scale, magnitude and nature of hydropower construction has been a big contributing factor to Himalayan disasters in recent years," she said. "It is tragic that we waited for Joshimath to pay attention."


In a 2021 report, the International Energy Agency (IEA) described hydropower as "the backbone of low-carbon electricity generation", saying it should be on the agenda for countries trying to meet their net-zero emissions goals.

India is the world's fifth-largest hydropower producer, with the IEA projecting the South Asian nation will play a key role in boosting global hydropower capacity by close to a fifth this decade.

Until the 1960s, India derived almost half of its electricity from hydro -- but that has since fallen to about 12%, as power generation from coal picked up.

The government is still expanding coal mines and opening new ones, citing the need for energy security. But it is also promoting hydropower and announced investments in a new project barely two days after Joshimath's land subsidence hit the headlines in early this month.

In a bid to boost capacity in 2019, the government declared hydroelectric projects larger than 25MW a renewable energy source, and made it obligatory for power utilities to use hydro for a share of their supply.

SK Singal, a professor in the hydro and renewable energy department at the Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, said dams and reservoirs can cut the risk of flooding during the heavy cloudbursts increasingly being recorded in the Himalayas.

"Hydropower also helps maintain grid stability when solar and wind energy generation drops," he said, emphasising that facilities must be properly constructed to avoid problems.

Only two hydroelectric plants have been completed on time in the last two decades, government data shows.

As of 2020, 24 projects under construction, with combined capacity of about 11,350MW, had overrun on time or cost, according to a parliamentary committee report.

Among the reasons for the delays, the report cited local protests, poor geological conditions such as loose rocks, flash floods, land acquisition issues and funding constraints.

One official in Arunachal Pradesh pointed to a shortage of capable contractors to build hydropower projects in the state, noting almost all are in a "precarious" financial condition.

Experts and officials told Context projects had also lost commercial viability and are being scrapped because of policy changes made to accommodate environmental and social concerns, such as locals insisting on their right to water in rivers.

"There are challenges, but there is far greater potential in hydropower" compared to other renewables, Prof Singal said. Upcoming projects are being planned on the run-of-river model -- where flowing river water is directed through channels to drive a turbine -- moving away from construction of large dams.

Experts point out that run-of-river hydropower projects are cheaper to build and require less land, avoiding large-scale displacement.

Some states, meanwhile, are taking measures to help meet their targets.

Arunachal Pradesh, for example, has created a local development fund and aims to reduce the risk of disasters by installing early warning systems and measuring the carrying capacity of river basins, while a complaints mechanism is also being considered, a local official said.

But communities are not convinced their best interests are at the heart of India's clean energy push.


In pristine parts of India's northeastern state of Arunachal Pradesh, protests against dams and hydropower projects go back two decades when the first ones were mooted.

Through sit-ins, art, music and graffiti opposing displacement, the clearing of forests and loss of ways of life, communities in the lower Dibang Valley have raised questions as Joshimath residents are doing now.

"Communities are constantly told by the state that these projects will bring development, jobs, roads and electricity to remote areas," said Bhanu Tatak, a member of Dibang Resistance, a citizens' collective which is speaking out on the matter.

"But these should have happened anyway. There is no information shared with local communities on the exact nature of the project and proper consent is never taken," she said.

In neighbouring Manipur state, the Loktak hydro project has caused devastation downstream, according to Ram Wangkheirakpam, adviser to the All Loktak Lake Areas Fishers Union.

With river flow depending on how dam outlets are controlled, farmers are finding boulders and sand deposited on their land, while fishing as a livelihood "has almost died", he said.

"Climate solutions are being forced on marginalised communities and they are getting no benefits," said Wangkheirakpam, noting that even the provision of electricity often means getting only "a bulb or two".

In Joshimath, the market -- usually filled with tourists and pilgrims visiting Hindu and Sikh shrines at this time of year -- is deserted as people leave for nearby towns where they have friends and relatives.

Ms Sah, who has been recording residents' aid needs and mapping how the crisis is affecting children's education, said that even those living in supposedly safe zones like her are worried the damage will spread to their homes.

"You are tearing apart the mountains for this [hydropower] project," she said. "It is clean energy for officials -- not for us who are suffering its impact." REUTERS

Roli Srivastava is a Mumbai-based journalist with Thomson Reuters Foundation. Anuradha Nagaraj is a Chennai-based journalist with the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

Do you like the content of this article?