OPINION

Dance of discord

Re: "'Khon' dance no reason for discord", (Editorial, Dec 2).

It is nice that Cambodia's and Thailand's versions of the Indian epic have been awarded UN recognition. Who, other than that fugitive former Thai PM who famously boasted in March 2003 that "the UN is not my father", would not be proud of such august recognition to confirm their worth? Will the current PM now also start to admire the UN suggestions that Thailand respect democracy and human rights, or will he favour the policy of the great fugitive?

But I also wonder: could the Post kindly tell us how many Thai people have ever seen a khon performance, unless forced to sit through one on a school outing? How many Thais today have any interest in doing so? Is it closer to 10% of the population or to 1%? This is a relevant statistic, but I was unable to find any figures.

My guess is that it's much closer to 1% than to 10%, but I might be totally wrong. Like other myths of amazing Thainess, could it be that solid, factual statistics are banned on the grounds that they would reveal truths that do not comport with enforced fantasies? Is Thai nationalism founded on nothing more substantial than myths told by unseen players hiding behind masks lest reality become known? The symbolism seems all too literal.

In fairness, I am reminded of the West. Our cultural font is Homer's Iliad, yet how many citizens of Western nations have ever read him in any language? Brad Pitt and Eric Bana's mild-mannered version in Troy is nice, but that niceness doesn't really do Homer justice. How many have thrilled to that blood-soaked tale of vengeance, loyalty and humanity, complete with gore, sex, violence, betrayal, randy gods acting with full human capriciousness, and with a healthy contempt for decidedly non-divine but human kings?

These elements of Homer all helped the West rise above the despotic Middle East ruled over by the likes of the dictatorial Yahweh, who gave birth to the Christian God and then to Allah, all three claiming an unbelievable, and unbelievably inhuman, omnipotent benevolence that must be held in awe, or else.

Naturally, severe dissociation from reality goes hand in hand with frothing nationalism.

Re: "PM irked by criticism of polling map", (BP, Dec 1).

Gen Prayut said that redrawing of boundaries is based on the growing population size in each constituency compared to previous elections.

He is correct that as a given constituency's population rises or drops, its boundaries may change accordingly. However, the redrawing must not be to the advantage of a given political party. For example, say a given subdistrict is a pro-Pheu Thai area, which, if taken by itself, might merit one representative, who would, of course, be from Pheu Thai. This bloc might be gerrymandered in such a way that half went to one anti-Pheu Thai constituency and the rest to another anti-Pheu Thai constituency, depriving the pro-Pheu Thai residents of a voice.

The Election Commission's operations should be transparent, based on clear, measurable, relevant criteria. Political parties which feel discriminated against should take the EC to court immediately to seek redress.

Re: "Rail progress tracks full steam ahead", (BP, Dec 2).

I think one needs to keep in mind that Bangkok is definitely NOT Shanghai, and Thailand is definitely not China. Thais may be in awe at the Shanghai railway station complex, but then, the new "Hua Lamphong at Bang Sue" will never see the passenger volume of the Shanghai station, probably not even the volume of one of China's smaller stations. China's high speed rail connects areas much greater than the distances between Thailand's north and south.

China is not an example of a country Thailand should emulate. However, Thailand seems caught in the Chinese net, and in the future it may well be a satellite country, or, it may see its territories absorbed, like Tibet.

Time will tell, and time, like patience, are both Chinese virtues.

Contact: Bangkok Post Building 136 Na Ranong Road Klong Toey, Bangkok 10110 fax: +02 6164000 Email: postbag@bangkokpost.co.th

All letter writers must provide full name and address.

All published correspondence is subject to editing at our discretion.