Bitcoin beckons Asian mom-and-pop investors
published : 3 Jun 2017 at 14:49
writer: Reuters and Bloomberg
Long the preserve of geeky enthusiasts, bitcoin is going mainstream in Asia, attracting "Mrs Watanabe" -- the prototypical Japanese housewife investor -- along with Korean retirees and thousands of others trying to escape rock-bottom savings rates by investing in the cryptocurrency.
Asia's moms and pops, already regular investors in stock and futures markets, have been dazzled by bitcoin's 100% surge so far this year. In comparison, the broader Asian stocks benchmark has gained 17% over the same period.
Even after a tumble from last week's record high of US$2,779.08, bitcoin rose more than 60% in May alone -- driven higher in part by investors in Japan and South Korea stepping in as China cooled after a central bank crackdown earlier this year.
Over the last two weeks, and encouraged by Japan's recognition of bitcoin as legal tender in April, exchanges say interest has jumped from the two countries. Bitcoin trades at a premium in both countries, due to tough money-laundering rules that make it hard for people to move bitcoin in and out.
"After I first heard about the bitcoin scheme, I was so excited I couldn't sleep. It's like buying a dream," said Mutsuko Higo, a 55-year-old Japanese social insurance and labour consultant who bought around 200,000 yen ($1,800) worth of bitcoin in March to supplement her retirement savings.
"Everyone says we can't rely on Japanese pensions anymore," she said. "This worries me, so I started bitcoins."
Asia has proved fertile ground for bitcoin due to the region's thriving retail investment culture, where swapping investment tips is already common. China, Japan and South Korea are home to several of the world's busiest cryptocurrency exchanges, according to a ranking by CoinMarketCap.
"Right now, it's a form of speculation, like stocks," said Park Hyo-jin, a 27-year-old South Korean who owns around 3 million won ($2,700) worth of bitcoin. "I don't think anybody in South Korea buys bitcoin to use it."
The new law recognising digital currencies as a form of payment took effect in Japan in April, and businesses are also jumping on the bandwagon to accommodate bitcoin payments in line with new regulations.
The law also formalised rules around anti-money laundering and put in place standards for security and audits, in light of concerns that bitcoin is often used for illegal activities.
Bic Camera, one of the country’s biggest electronics retailers, began accepting bitcoin at two stores in Tokyo last month. The restaurant booking site Gurunavi will start letting diners pay with bitcoin later this year, the Nikkei newspaper reported.
And BITPoint Japan Co, the company behind Peach Aviation's move to let travellers use bitcoin to pay for tickets, is planning to give hundreds of thousands of Japanese retail outlets the ability to accept the digital currency.
While BITPoint operates as a bitcoin exchange, it’s pushing to promote the use of the cryptocurrency in stores and other retail outlets, instead of as a speculative instrument.
“We’re holding discussions with a retail-related company,” BITPoint president Genki Oda said in a recent interview. “By going through a company providing payment terminal services to shops, we have the possibility of increasing its use at one stroke. It’s easier than talking to lots of individual retailers.”
Asked about the recent climb in bitcoin’s value, Oda said he was wary of the sudden jump and did not think it would be sustainable. However, he notes that several large foreign-exchange brokerages will begin bitcoin trading in the coming months, boosting volumes.
Still, it’s unclear whether bitcoin payments can become more than a marketing gimmick. The biggest hurdles include long network confirmation times and high transaction fees. While many bitcoin community members rallied around a new proposal last week to fix the problem, deep differences within the group led to several similar solutions falling through since 2015.
Bitcoin is largely unregulated across Asia, while rules governing bitcoin exchanges can be patchy.
In Hong Kong, bitcoin exchanges operate under money service operator licences -- like money changers -- while in South Korea they are regulated similar to online shopping malls, trading physical goods. Often there are no rules on investor protection.
Investors Park and Higo say they were drawn to bitcoin by friends. Others are attracted through seminars, social media groups and blogs penned by amateur investors.
Noboru Hanaki, a 27-year-old Japanese web marketer and bitcoin investor, said his personal finance blog gets around 30,000 page views each month. The most popular post is an explanation of bitcoin, he said, noting that when the bitcoin price surged last month, readership of the article doubled.
Rachel Poole, a Hong Kong-based kindergarten teacher, said she read about bitcoin in the media, and bought five bitcoins in March for around HK$40,000 ($5,100) after studying blogs on the topic. She kept four as an investment and has made HK$12,000 tax-free trading the fifth after classes.
"I wish I'd done it earlier," she said.
Not everyone is making money. The bitcoin frenzy has spawned scams, with police in South Korea last month uncovering a $55-million cryptocurrency pyramid scheme that sucked in thousands of homemakers, workers and self-employed businessmen seduced by slick marketing and promises of wealth.
Seminars in Tokyo, Seoul and Hong Kong promote similar multi-level marketing schemes that require investors to pay an upfront membership fee of as much as $9,000. Members are encouraged to promote the cryptocurrency and bring in new members in return for some bitcoins and other benefits.
One such Tokyo scheme offered members-only shopping websites that accept bitcoin, 24-hour assistance for car and computer problems, and bitcoin-based gifts when a member gets married, has a baby -- or even dies, according to marketing materials seen by Reuters.
Leonhard Weese, president of the Bitcoin Association of Hong Kong and a bitcoin investor, warned amateur investors against speculating in the digital currency.
"Trading carries huge risk: there is no investor protection and plenty of market manipulation and insider trading. Some of the exchanges cannot be trusted in my opinion."
Some larger exchanges have voluntarily adopted security measures and compensation guarantees, according to their websites, although there are dozens of smaller platforms operating more or less unchecked.
In South Korea, the Financial Services Commission (FSC) has set up a task force to explore regulating cryptocurrencies, but it has not set a timeline for publishing its conclusions, an official there said.
In Japan -- where memories are still fresh of the spectacular 2014 collapse of Mt Gox, the world's biggest bitcoin exchange at the time -- the Financial Services Agency (FSA) said it supervises bitcoin exchanges, but not traders or investors.
"The government is not guaranteeing the value of cryptocurrencies. We are asking for bitcoin exchanges to fully explain the risk of sharp price moves," an FSA official said.